2026 Fantasy Baseball: Uncover 4 Under-the-Radar Sleepers

Bassyonni

Published: March 16, 2026 9:12 AM ET

The fantasy baseball landscape is constantly evolving, presenting opportunities for savvy managers to capitalize on emerging talent. As we approach the 2026 season, a focus on post-hype sleepers can yield excellent value during drafts. Here are four under-the-radar players who might exceed expectations this year.

2026 Fantasy Baseball: Uncover 4 Under-the-Radar Sleepers

1. Francisco Alvarez (C – NYM)

After a challenging 2024 season marred by injuries, Francisco Alvarez remains a catcher with significant potential. The young Venezuelan seemed set for a breakout after a strong finish in 2025, hitting eight home runs in just 139 plate appearances following the All-Star break. Although his batting average hovered around .209 in 2023, his 25 home runs demonstrate his power potential. At just 24 years old, he is poised to improve and could become a top-tier fantasy catcher.

2. Bryce Eldridge (1B – SF)

Bryce Eldridge had a tough introduction to the majors, hitting only .107 in his late-season call-up. Nonetheless, he has showcased his abilities during spring training, posting a .967 OPS and demonstrating improved performance. In 2025, Eldridge accumulated an .836 OPS with 18 deep drives at the Triple-A level. With an average draft position outside the top 300, many fantasy managers might overlook his potential. Eldridge has the talent to earn a regular spot in the Giants’ lineup soon.

3. Evan Carter (OF – TEX)

Evan Carter made headlines after his debut in September 2023, hitting .306 and contributing to the Rangers’ World Series victory. However, injuries and inconsistent production followed him into 2024. Last season, he managed a .728 OPS in 63 games. Despite this, Carter displayed excellent fielding skills and speed with 14 stolen bases. At only 23 years old, Carter’s plate discipline and high on-base percentage could lead to a bounce-back year.

4. Cade Cavalli (SP – PHI)

After overcoming a series of health issues, Cade Cavalli has been named the Opening Day starter for the Nationals. With only 11 MLB starts to his name, expectations are high. Last September, he maintained a respectable 4.25 ERA over 48.2 innings. Notably, his impressive 54.8% groundball rate and solid command with a 6.3% walk rate suggest potential for further improvement. Though he might not become a fantasy ace, Cavalli could serve as a reliable middle-tier pitching option.

Conclusion

As the 2026 fantasy baseball season approaches, targeting players like Alvarez, Eldridge, Carter, and Cavalli can provide strategic advantages. They offer upside and the potential for breakout performances, making them valuable assets for fantasy teams.