Andy Weir Criticizes Modern ‘Star Trek’ After Paramount Rejects His Pitch

Bassyonni

Published: March 30, 2026 3:43 PM ET

Andy Weir Criticizes Modern ‘Star Trek’ After Paramount Rejects His Pitch

Andy Weir, the acclaimed author known for his bestselling novel “Project Hail Mary,” has recently criticized the direction of modern “Star Trek.” Despite his successful track record, Paramount decided against his pitch for a new series within the franchise. This decision highlights a growing disconnect between contemporary Star Trek offerings and the original series’ charm.

Weir’s Take on Modern Star Trek

During a recent appearance on the podcast “Critical Drinker,” Weir articulated his frustrations. He remarked that while the original “Star Trek” series influenced modern science fiction, current installments have strayed from this foundation. He stated, “All modern science fiction TV shows and movies have been heavily influenced by the original ‘Star Trek,’ except for the current batch of Star Trek shows.”

Weir’s Personal Connection

As a member of Generation X, Weir grew up with classic science fiction shows. He expressed nostalgia for the original “Star Trek” and “Lost in Space,” stating, “There wasn’t really much in the way of new sci-fi until [The Next Generation].” This personal experience underscores his passion for traditional storytelling in the genre.

Critique of Recent Series

While discussing the fate of “Starfleet Academy,” Weir acknowledged some modern series. He expressed appreciation for “Strange New Worlds” but was less enthusiastic about others, saying, “Lower Decks… was entertaining and fun. All the others, they can go.” His candid criticism raises questions about the creative direction of the franchise.

Behind the Pitch

Weir revealed he pitched a “Star Trek” show to Paramount, engaging with executive producer Alex Kurtzman. His pitch was ultimately rejected, leading to his blunt commentary on the newer series. “I don’t like a lot of the new Trek… But at the same time, those shows are not good,” he remarked.

Social Commentary in Star Trek

Weir has a long-standing aversion to social commentary in storytelling. In previous interviews, he emphasized his desire for entertainment rather than political discourse. “I just want to be entertained, not preached at by the author,” he noted. This perspective contrasts sharply with the themes entrenched in “Star Trek,” which often reflects social issues through its narratives.

The Future of Star Trek

Though Weir enjoys certain series, his desire for a focus on action rather than social dialogues suggests a different vision for “Star Trek.” The franchise has traditionally blended entertainment with commentary, engaging audiences on multiple levels. Weir’s outlook may not align with what many fans appreciate about “Star Trek.”

Project Hail Mary in Theaters

As audiences enjoy “Project Hail Mary,” which centers on collaboration among Earth’s governments to address an ecological crisis, Weir’s critique of “Star Trek” may serve to highlight a broader conversation about storytelling in science fiction.