Caleb Thielbar’s Error Highlights Matt Shaw’s Unusual First Base Role

In a tense game between the Chicago Cubs and the Pittsburgh Pirates, a throwing error from Cubs reliever Caleb Thielbar in the 11th inning proved pivotal. This mistake allowed the winning run to score, contributing to the Pirates’ 4-3 victory. Meanwhile, the Cubs were unable to take advantage of a similar opportunity presented to them earlier in the inning.

Impact of Michael Busch’s Struggles

The error by Thielbar raises questions about the performance of Cubs first baseman Michael Busch, who is currently experiencing an unusual slump. Busch’s streak of 0 for 30 at the plate is notably his longest in the majors. His struggles continued as he failed to secure a hit in this game.

Manager Craig Counsell acknowledged Busch’s ongoing difficulties, stating, “We’re trying to figure it out.” As the Cubs searched for a way to rally, Busch was removed from the game after going 0 for 3 with two strikeouts, replaced by Carson Kelly.

Matt Shaw’s Unique Role

With Busch out, Matt Shaw took to first base wearing a mitt for only the first time in his professional career. Despite little preparation for the position, Shaw played a crucial role in the game that day. However, Thielbar’s wild throw overshadowed Shaw’s potential impact.

Game Highlights

• Pirates took an early 3-0 lead, with starting pitcher Edward Cabrera starting strong.
• The Cubs made a late push, with a potential game-tying hit from Alex Bregman.
• Shaw found himself stranded on third base in the ninth inning.
• The Cubs left 16 runners on base, while the Pirates left 13.

In the 11th inning, Thielbar initially looked in control, striking out the first two batters. However, after intentionally walking O’Neil Cruz, he misplayed a tapper from Brandon Lowe that cost the Cubs dearly. The resulting throw was errant, leading to Nick Gonzales scoring the winning run.

Looking Ahead

The Cubs continue to search for their first comeback win in the 2026 season. Despite the setbacks, players like Bregman remain optimistic about improving execution as the season progresses.

Game Notes

• Seiya Suzuki was not in the starting lineup but made an appearance as a pinch hitter.
• The Cubs’ pitching rotation for the upcoming series against the Phillies has yet to be officially announced.