Mel Kiper Predicts NY Giants Will Choose Caleb Downs at No. 5 Over Styles
In his most recent mock draft for 2026, Mel Kiper forecasts that the New York Giants will select safety Caleb Downs from Ohio State with the fifth overall pick. This prediction is based on team evaluations, needs, and insights from NFL executives and coaches.
Caleb Downs: The Top Safety Prospect
If selected, Downs will be the first safety drafted in the top five since Eric Berry in 2010. Kiper highlights that teaming Downs with Jevon Holland could significantly enhance the Giants’ secondary. His remarkable instincts on the field would complement the team’s defensive strategies.
Kiper notes the potential competition for the Giants between three noteworthy Ohio State players, including receivers Carnell Tate and Malik Nabers, alongside linebacker Sonny Styles. However, Kiper consistently points back to Downs’ unique abilities as the key factor in this choice.
Reasons for Selecting Downs
- First top-five safety pick since 2010.
- Complementary skills with Jevon Holland.
- Great fit for defensive coordinator Dennard Wilson’s system.
Round Two Predictions
In the second round, Kiper predicts the Giants will choose Keylan Rutledge, a guard from Georgia Tech, with the 37th pick. With a college career spanning 43 games and only two sacks allowed, Rutledge is viewed as a solid addition to the offensive line.
Despite the signing of Daniel Faalele, Kiper believes it would be wise for the Giants to strengthen their interior line. The competition is tough, as many analysts rank other prospects, like Chase Bisontis from Texas A&M, higher than Rutledge.
Analysis of Offensive Line Needs
- Improving depth and performance of the offensive line.
- Rutledge’s college performance indicates potential for a starting role.
- Key positions filled to enhance team dynamics.
With Kiper’s predictions for both rounds, the Giants have significant decisions ahead. Selecting Caleb Downs at No. 5 could reshape their defense, while adding Keylan Rutledge addresses pressing needs on the offensive front. As the draft approaches, the choices made will be pivotal for the team’s future direction.
