Washington State Patrol solves 35-year Helen Doe case — Mary Ellen Mollie Mccullough Update

Mary Ellen Mollie McCullough update: Washington State Patrol identified Helen Doe after 35 years, using DNA and genealogy to close a crash case.

Published
2 Min Read
Washington State Patrol solves 35-year Helen Doe case — Mary Ellen Mollie Mccullough Update

Washington State Patrol detectives have identified the woman known for years as Helen Doe as Mary Ellen “Mollie” McCullough, closing a 35-year Mary Ellen Mollie McCullough update tied to a 1991 crash on Interstate 5 near Kalama. The identification gives her family an answer after decades without contact and sets up the return of her cremated remains to Cambridge, Ohio.

- Advertisement -

McCullough was 34 when she disappeared in 1991 after leaving home to catch a ride. Her family had not heard from her since then, and investigators later matched the crash victim to her through DNA testing and family-tree research.

Washington State Patrol and Othram Labs

The case began on May 14, 1991, when two semi-trucks crashed on southbound Interstate 5 near Kalama. The fire killed one driver and a female passenger, but investigators could not identify the passenger. She was buried in an unmarked grave in Longview.

Washington State Patrol detectives reopened the case in 2014 and worked with the Cowlitz County coroner, a King County Medical Examiner forensic anthropologist, the Puyallup Tribe and Othram Labs in the effort to identify her. That process started with exhumation and a DNA profile, then moved into genealogy work that linked the remains to McCullough’s family.

Stacy Moate and Renee Kerr

Detective Sgt Stacy Moate used family-tree leads for several years with help from Othram experts and volunteer genealogist Renee Kerr. In 2022, Othram Labs created a more advanced DNA profile that indicated Scottish, Irish and English ancestry, narrowing the search before a relative match emerged.

- Advertisement -

On Aug. 6, 2026, Moate called Michael McCullough, one of the names on a list of possible relatives. Michael McCullough said his sister Mollie had disappeared in the early 1990s, and additional DNA testing later showed he was the unidentified woman’s brother.

Michael McCullough and the family

After the identification, Mike thanked Washington State Patrol, the detectives who worked on the case, Othram Labs, the Puyallup Tribe and the Cowlitz County community. He said, “From the bottom of our hearts, thank you for never giving up on our Mollie,” and the family plans to bring her cremated remains to her birthplace in Cambridge, Ohio.

The unanswered question now is what happened after Mollie McCullough left home in 1991 to catch a ride, because investigators have identified who she was but not the circumstances that led to her disappearance.

Advertisement
Share This Article
On-the-ground news correspondent reporting from city halls, courtrooms, and press briefings. Holder of a Columbia Journalism School degree.