Sony defeats £2 billion Uk Tribunal Playstation Monopoly Case claim

Sony defeated a £2 billion UK tribunal PlayStation monopoly case over PlayStation Store pricing after a 30-day hearing in London.

Published
2 Min Read
Sony defeats £2 billion Uk Tribunal Playstation Monopoly Case claim

Sony defeated the UK tribunal PlayStation monopoly case on Tuesday, when the Competition Appeal Tribunal dismissed a £2 billion claim over PlayStation Store pricing. The case had been brought on behalf of an estimated 12.2 million gamers by consumer champion Alex Neill.

- Advertisement -

The tribunal heard the case in London over 30 days before publishing its judgment. It rejected the claim in full, ending a challenge that said Sony had charged excessive and unfair sums for downloads from its PlayStation Store.

Alex Neill and the 12.2 million

Neill brought the claim for PlayStation users who alleged Sony had removed all actual and potential competition in digital games for the console. The scale of the case was set by the estimated 12.2 million gamers included in the claim, which turned a store-pricing dispute into a competition test with wide reach.

Robert Palmer KC told the tribunal that it was a contractual condition of publishing content for PlayStation that it not be digitally distributed through any other means than through the PlayStation network and store without Sony's consent. He said Sony designed the console and operating system to prevent downloads from any other source and imposed restrictive licence conditions on users.

Competition Appeal Tribunal in London

Sony told the court that allowing third-party stores for downloads would create security and privacy risks. It also said it invests heavily in hardware, sells consoles at a relatively low margin to build a user base, and uses commission on digital sales as part of a cross-subsidisation strategy to cover hardware costs.

- Advertisement -

The tribunal said its market definitions were unsafe for assessing Sony's conduct. It also found that PlayStation purchasers would be likely to make informed choices when buying consoles, including the prices of games.

Sony's pricing model

In its judgment, the tribunal said it was not satisfied that Sony was dominant in the market. It was also not satisfied that Sony's practices were exclusionary or exploitative, and dismissed the case in its entirety.

The ruling leaves Sony's PlayStation Store pricing model intact after the challenge over digital game charges. The source does not say whether the claimants will appeal.

Advertisement
Share This Article
Investigative news reporter specialising in local government, public policy, and social issues. Two-time Regional Press Award winner.