Kelly Coate rejects Ofqual return to in-person exams

Kelly Coate rejected an Ofqual-backed return to in-person exams, after new guidance on AI assessment prompted debate over how universities should test students.

Published
2 Min Read
Kelly Coate rejects Ofqual return to in-person exams

Kelly Coate rejected a return to in-person exams as the response to AI in higher education, saying that would be the worst thing the sector could do. The provost of Richmond American University London made the case during a webinar hosted by the Higher Education Policy Institute and learning platform Studiosity after the Office for Students issued new guidance on assessment.

- Advertisement -

“I think the worst thing we could do as a whole-institution approach is [to] go back to in-person exams,” Coate said. She added: “I was hugely disappointed that the Ofs report referenced in-person exams as a possibly secure method of assessing students.”

Office for Students guidance

The Office for Students said earlier this month that it wanted valid and reliable assessment in the age of AI. It encouraged greater use of in-person testing, presentations and vivas, but it did not order institutions to use any one method.

That leaves universities to decide how far to move away from remote essays and other take-home work. The debate now sits between those who want more secure assessment methods and those who argue that a sector-wide return to exams would be the wrong answer to widespread AI use.

Josh Freeman on assessment

Josh Freeman, the strategy manager at the Office for Students, said the report was intended to set a framework rather than dictate practice. “it is not our place to tell institutions exactly what they should do, but rather to set the framework within which higher education institutions operate,” he said. “We hope that this has been a helpful intervention.”

- Advertisement -

Freeman also said the Making AI Work for Students report was based on conversations with nearly 100 students and 200 teaching staff members. He said many assessments used in the sector just aren’t fit for purpose, and warned that a remote take-home essay checked with an AI detector is not reliable because AI can complete that essay to a high standard in ways that are not detectable.

Making AI Work for Students

Freeman said there was also an equality of opportunity issue, because some students can benefit from more expensive paid-for AI services and potentially better grades. Coate’s objection points to the practical choice now facing institutions: whether to lean further into in-person exams, or redesign assessment in ways that reflect how AI is already being used.

Sam Illingworth, professor of critical AI literacy at Edinburgh Napier University, argued that any wider framework should be built with educators, trade unions, administrators and students at the start. “What I don’t want to see is lip service from a government agency putting something through without thinking about all of the actors that are involved,” he said. The argument over assessment is now less about whether AI is present than about which methods universities will trust next.

Advertisement
TAGGED:
Share This Article
On-the-ground news correspondent reporting from city halls, courtrooms, and press briefings. Holder of a Columbia Journalism School degree.