Greenpeace International appears in a Business Day letter that argues climate funding for developing countries should first target scope 2 and 3 emissions, not only renewables. The letter says African countries with crude oil resources but little or no refining capacity need a phased approach that addresses fuel imports, inflationary shocks, and carbon capture.
The letter asks whether a different approach should apply where countries are net importers of refined fuel and energy. It says phase one should eliminate scope 2 and 3 emissions, while phase two should optimise renewable energy use and prioritise grid expansion for heavy industry based on consumption patterns to reduce curtailment costs.
Business Day and David Wolpert
The letter is addressed to David Wolpert, and it uses the poultry trade debate to make its broader point about policy design. Wolpert’s referenced line, “Consumers risk being sidelined in the poultry trade debate,” is tied to a dispute over how trade rules can land on consumers when policy is negotiated without them in mind.
That same argument is then extended to climate finance. The letter says exclusive renewable energy will not meet the socio-economic developmental needs of many developing countries, and it says fossil fuels should not be vilified in this context. Instead, it calls for funding that supports local refining capacity and carbon capture technologies before a full renewable buildout.
South Africa and Agoa
The letter widens from climate finance to South Africa, Johannesburg, Gauteng, Eskom and Agoa. It says Johannesburg was one of the world’s richest cities in the 1960s and 1970s, when mining and associated manufacturing depended on cheap electricity supplied by Eskom and a rail network that connected Gauteng to the coast.
It also says the DA’s attempt to make Gauteng great again through efficiency and rooting out corruption is laudable, and that the monetary fiat craze is ending while gold is again the financial reserve of choice. On trade, the letter says the US forced the Agoa chicken quota on South Africa in 2016 as a condition for renewing benefits to other South African industries, and that the quota is currently 73,000 tonnes a year.
The letter says South Africa will be booted out of Agoa next January. It leaves climate policy, trade exposure, and industrial capacity tied together in one warning: funding decisions that ignore refining, power supply, and manufacturing can leave development plans dependent on imports, quotas, and unstable inputs.







