Billy Allison has been found guilty of murdering Matthew O'Gara after a punch to the neck on a dancefloor at Rico and Loren bar in Lichfield. He was also found guilty of causing grievous bodily harm with intent to Adam Cooper, ending a trial over a violent incident that left one man dead and another badly injured.
Matthew O'Gara at Rico and Loren
Matthew O'Gara, who ran The Plough on the outskirts of Lichfield, died in hospital two days after the attack on 24 May. The injury was severe: he suffered two broken bones and a split artery in his neck, and that blood loss left him unconscious until his death.
The court heard that the punch could be heard over the bar's DJ sound system. That detail cuts through the noise of a crowded venue and shows how a single blow, thrown in public, turned into a fatal assault within days.
Adam Cooper and the verdict
Adam Cooper was punched twice in the same incident and suffered a fractured eye socket and nose. The jury of 7 men and 5 women returned guilty verdicts against Allison on both counts, closing a case that involved two victims from one night out in Lichfield, Staffordshire.
Allison had been drinking in Lichfield with Charlotte Dean, Ryan Bridge and Ben Cullen on the day of the attack, and he had been drunk and taken cocaine during the day. He had admitted manslaughter before the trial but denied murder, yet the jury still found the higher charge proved.
Lisa Holland on accountability
Detective Inspector Lisa Holland said, “I would like to pay tribute to Matthew's family for the dignity, courage and patience they have shown throughout this difficult process.” She also said, “While today's verdict cannot bring Matthew back, I hope it provides his family and friends with a measure of justice and reassurance that Allison has been held accountable for his actions.”
Matthew O'Gara's family said, “While the conclusion of the court proceedings has brought a measure of justice, it can never replace the loss we have suffered or bring Matthew back,” adding, “Our heartfelt thanks also go to Matthew's friends, whose unwavering support has meant so much to us during this ordeal.” They said, “He remains deeply loved, will be forever missed, and will always hold a special place in our hearts.”
Allison is due to be sentenced on 5 January, and that hearing will settle the immediate criminal outcome after a verdict that already answers the central dispute in the case: the jury accepted murder, not the manslaughter plea he had put forward.







