Elissa Slotkin rebukes Aaron Reitz over 5-lawmaker letter

Elissa Slotkin told Aaron Reitz his investigation threat was baseless and said he should withdraw the letter immediately over her speech.

Published
2 Min Read
Elissa Slotkin rebukes Aaron Reitz over 5-lawmaker letter

Elissa Slotkin wrote to Aaron Reitz on Wednesday and told him his threat of investigating her political speech was baseless. She said the remarks were protected by the First Amendment and asked him to withdraw the letter immediately.

- Advertisement -

Slotkin also said the Speech or Debate clause bars prosecution of a legislator for conducting an investigation or performing other legislative acts. In her letter, she said her statements were made consistent with her right to freedom of speech and that Reitz’s public threats were evidence of publicity rather than a legitimate inquiry.

Aaron Reitz letter dispute

Reitz posted letters on social media to five Democratic lawmakers, including Slotkin. One of those letters suggested her comments about congressional oversight and deterrence for people considering joining the Donald Trump administration could amount to a criminal civil rights offense.

That letter drew scrutiny because Reitz also told News this week that he was not interested in chilling free speech. Slotkin’s response put those two positions side by side: a public warning that her speech could trigger criminal scrutiny, and a denial that he meant to suppress speech at all.

Todd Blanche and legal scrutiny

The dispute follows a separate clash earlier this year, when Slotkin and five other sitting Democratic lawmakers were targeted over a video they posted to social media reminding members of the military and intelligence communities that they should not obey unlawful orders. Allies of Jeanine Pirro tried to indict the six Democrats for that speech, but federal grand jurors unanimously rejected the attempt.

- Advertisement -

Slotkin’s attorney, Prett Bharara, had previously cautioned Attorney General Todd Blanche against following Donald Trump’s public instruction to look into Slotkin’s political speech. Blanche later said Slotkin’s words alone were absolutely not a crime, and he said there were no ongoing criminal investigations into words that incoming senators or congressmen have said.

What Reitz must answer

Slotkin’s letter leaves Reitz with a narrow choice: withdraw the threat or keep pressing a theory that has already drawn legal scrutiny and public pushback. The unanswered issue is the legal basis for treating a senator’s remarks about oversight as a criminal civil rights offense, and Reitz has not publicly explained it.

Advertisement
Share This Article
On-the-ground news correspondent reporting from city halls, courtrooms, and press briefings. Holder of a Columbia Journalism School degree.