Lord Mulholland told a committee of MPs that Alex Salmond once asked him to investigate a pardon for William Wallace. He said the conversation was “humorous,” but it did not lead to any formal action.
The evidence came during an inquiry into the dual role of the Lord Advocate, which is also examining the Peter Murrell case. That inquiry was launched after revelations about confidential briefing raised claims of political interference in the independent judicial process.
Lord Mulholland and Alex Salmond
Lord Mulholland said he was unsure whether Salmond was serious when he raised the pardon idea. The former Lord Advocate said he had never experienced any attempt at political interference in his time in the role, and he said he had never briefed politicians on the evidence in any investigation.
Mulholland also said the dual role of the Lord Advocate was useful in formulating policy and advising Scottish ministers on high-profile cases. He said the role should not be split, which places him at one end of a debate that the committee is weighing through evidence from former law officers.
Peter Murrell case inquiry
The inquiry was triggered by earlier revelations that Dorothy Bain sent minutes to John Swinney before confidential details of the Peter Murrell case became public. The briefing included the sum of money Peter Murrell was accused of embezzling and an estimate of when the case would come to court.
Bain said it was longstanding practice for ministers to be updated on high-profile cases. Opposition parties said the disclosures raised claims of political interference, and MPs opened their inquiry after those revelations.
Angus Sinclair briefing
Mulholland also told the committee that he had briefed Alex Salmond on the decision to apply for the acquittal of Angus Sinclair to be overturned. He said that information was passed on shortly before it became public.
Patricia Ferguson MP pressed him on whether he would brief ministers on a case involving an MSP, and he replied: “I don't think I would, to be honest… I can't swear to it, but the way I would think, I can't imagine me doing that.” The committee’s work continues with that question of ministerial briefing still central to how it assesses the Lord Advocate’s role.







