Should I spare Arnold in GTA 6 comes down to a dockside choice at the end of the Hey Arnold mission, where Jason can spare him or kill him after a chase. The walkthrough starts at Brian’s hotel marker in Chapter 1, then moves straight into a pickup, a pursuit, and a final decision that changes how the encounter ends.
Brian starts the chase
Jason begins the Hey Arnold mission by meeting Brian at the hotel marked on the map, then driving Brian’s pickup truck to confront a supplier who has ghosted him. Cal has to be picked up before the group reaches Arnold, so the mission is built around movement rather than a simple meet-and-talk sequence.
Arnold turns confrontational and drives off once the group arrives, which pushes the mission into a chase. Jason can shoot while driving with R1 or RB, then keep pressure on Arnold as he tears down a narrow road with jumps before running on foot.
The dockside choice
The final decision arrives at the end of a dock, where the player chooses whether to spare Arnold or kill him. If Arnold is spared, he swims away. That makes the encounter less of a fixed takedown and more of a branch point, with the player deciding whether the mission closes on restraint or execution.
Brian had set the whole sequence in motion because Arnold had ghosted him, but the mission does not force a clean resolution. Arnold goes from missing supplier to chased target to a choice at the water’s edge, and the game leaves the player to decide whether the pursuit ends with a live escape route or a dead end.
Brian, Kenton, Island Dreams
After the mission, Brian introduces Jason to Kenton at a gathering in Brian’s pool with his wife, and Kenton is described as someone who does illicit diving to hunt for treasure out at sea. The game then points the player toward the Island Dreams mission, which makes the dockside choice feel like a chapter turn rather than a throwaway scene.
The practical read for players is simple: if you want the cleanest mission clear, the choice is already built into the script, and if you want to see every branch, the dock is where you need to pause and decide. Jason’s next step is already laid out, but Arnold’s fate stays in the player’s hands at the exact moment the chase ends.







