Dietmar Hamann believes Manchester City should face financial compensation and a hefty points deduction if the club's appeal in the Premier League case fails. City are still waiting to discover their fate after being found guilty of 114 monetary regulation breaches, with a verdict expected in the next few weeks.
The former Manchester City midfielder said there has been plenty of speculation about what could happen, but he was clear that the punishment should be serious if the appeal does not go the club's way. Hamann said he has heard talk of everything from City getting off the charges to a 70-point deduction, while others believe any sanctions may be delayed until next season.
“If the appeal fails, which I think is coming out in the next few weeks, there's got to be financial compensation to the other clubs and on top a hefty points deduction,” Hamann said. “But then the Championship clubs already mentioned that they don't want them down there because they take one place of only three that go up.”
Why the Championship angle matters
Hamann's point helps explain why the possible punishment reaches beyond Manchester City themselves. If City were handed a severe deduction and ended up in the Championship, it would create a major question for clubs in that division. As Hamann noted, there are only three promotion places available, and some Championship clubs do not want one of those spots taken up by a team with City's resources and recent history.
Manchester City have pleaded innocence throughout the case, and sanctions have been mooted across the last two years. The club's recent success only adds to the scale of the discussion. Over Pep Guardiola's 10-year stint in Manchester, City have collected 20 trophies, including eight Premier League titles, as well as domestic cup and Champions League triumphs.
Hamann said a significant punishment would be difficult for anyone to judge from the outside, but he expects a strong response if the appeal fails. “So, it's a decision I wouldn't like to make. But anything other than financial compensation and a hefty points deduction, I'd be surprised,” he said.
Danny Mills was even more direct about the prospect of a light punishment. “If it's a slap on the wrist, it's an absolute farce,” he said.
Manchester City last played in the EFL ranks in 2001-02, which is why the possibility of any lower-division return would be such a major shock. For now, the club remains in limbo, waiting for the appeal verdict that could define the next stage of the case and the scale of any punishment that follows.







