Finn Wittrock plays Milton Hershey in Hershey, the Mark Waters biopic reviewed after its Thanksgiving release push. The film runs 1 hour 50 minutes and carries a PG rating, putting a polished studio frame around the founder of the Hershey Company.
The review opens with a close-up of a Hershey’s Kiss and a title card calling the story “based on the unlikely true story.” That setup signals the movie’s intent immediately: sell a rise-to-prominence arc in a package that looks designed for broad holiday viewing.
Waters, Wittrock, and the cast
Mark Waters directs from a script by Sharon Paul and Timothy Michael Hayes, with Alexandra Daddario, Alan Ruck and Richard Kind in support. The film begins in 1870 with a young Milton growing up in a Mennonite community in rural Pennsylvania, then moves through the apprenticeship under Joseph Royer that teaches him candy-making methods.
Milton later opens a shop specializing in caramels, then a store in Lancaster, Pennsylvania, that takes off after a bulk order from a visiting Englishman. The story then shifts to chocolate, after a salesman from a German chocolate company tells him, “I think you’re missing out on what’s next.”
Caramels to chocolate
Finn Wittrock’s character answers that pivot with the line, “Caramels are a fad, but chocolate is permanent.” That is the film’s business logic in one sentence: it turns Hershey’s move from one sweet to another into the engine of a company origin story.
The review also says the movie shows Milton meeting Kitty during his rise and eventually turning the village where he grew up into the company town that still bears his name. It presents him as the kind of builder studios like to turn into a clean narrative of ambition, and here the review is blunt about how neatly that narrative is packaged.
What the review omits
The criticism lands on what the film leaves out. The review says Hershey treats Milton as benevolent and ignores the violent labor disputes that occurred in later years, while also omitting that admission to the school was restricted to whites and that Black students were not admitted until 1968.
That kind of trimming matters because the film is not just a family-friendly biopic; it is also a portrait of a company founder whose legacy reached far beyond candy. For viewers, the movie arrives with a polished shape and a narrowed frame, which means the most useful question is not whether Wittrock can carry the role, but how much of Milton Hershey’s history the film chooses to leave outside the frame.
For anyone heading to the film for Thanksgiving, the review suggests a straightforward choice: take it as a tidy origin story with a strong lead performance, or read its silence as part of the story it is telling. Hershey is built to move quickly, but the history around Milton Hershey is still doing the heavier work.







