James P. Sullivan refuses Trump third-term answer on 22nd Amendment

James P. Sullivan declined to say whether Donald Trump could run again under the 22nd Amendment during his Senate nomination hearing Wednesday.

Published
2 Min Read
James P. Sullivan refuses Trump third-term answer on 22nd Amendment

James P. Sullivan refused to say whether Donald Trump could run for a third presidential term when Chris Coons pressed him on the 22nd Amendment during his Senate nomination hearing on Wednesday. Sullivan, a Texas Supreme Court justice nominated by President Donald Trump for a federal judgeship in Texas, said the issue fell within Canon 5 limits for a judicial nominee.

- Advertisement -

Coons asked Sullivan to explain the amendment first. After a hint, Sullivan recalled that it bars a person from being elected president more than twice, then stopped short when Coons asked whether Trump could run again.

Coons presses Sullivan

“As a nominee for a federal district court, it would be a violation, I believe, of Canon 5 for me to opine on something like that,” Sullivan said. He added that the question “seems like it’s the sort of thing that is the subject of ongoing political debate.”

Coons rejected that framing. “The question of whether someone can serve a third term as president of the United States, I think, is only unresolved in the mind of President Trump, who has repeatedly said that he’s thinking he might run for a third time,” he said. He added, “I don’t believe it is the subject of political debate.”

Sullivan’s Texas record

Sullivan was appointed by Greg Abbott in early 2025 and served just under two years on Texas’s high court after a vacancy opened. He previously served as general counsel to the governor from 2018 to 2025 and is a member of the Federalist Society.

- Advertisement -

Trump nominated Sullivan to become a federal judge within Texas days after Sullivan lost his reelection bid earlier this month. That sequence puts his answers at Wednesday’s hearing under direct scrutiny because the judicial vacancy now depends on the Senate nomination process, not on his state court service.

22nd Amendment and ABA Canon

The 22nd Amendment says a person cannot be elected president more than twice. Sullivan’s refusal rested on ABA Canon 5, which includes a subsection barring judicial candidates from making statements that commit them on cases, controversies or issues likely to come before the court.

That leaves Sullivan’s nomination tied to a narrow procedural question: whether senators accept his refusal as compliance with judicial ethics, or treat it as an evasion of a direct constitutional question. If the nomination advances, the record from Wednesday will remain part of how senators judge his fitness for a federal seat.

Advertisement
Share This Article
Investigative news reporter specialising in local government, public policy, and social issues. Two-time Regional Press Award winner.