Nicholas Evans says Home Birth deaths might have been avoided in NSW

An NSW inquest heard four babies who died after free and home births might have survived with routine checks and follow-up in Lismore.

Published
2 Min Read
Nicholas Evans says Home Birth deaths might have been avoided in NSW

An inquest in Lismore heard that four babies who died in New South Wales after free birth or home birth might have survived with routine checks and follow-up. Baby DH died about eight hours after a free birth with a doula present and no medical professionals. Experts said the missing care may have changed the outcome before and after birth.

- Advertisement -

Nicholas Evans at Lismore

Nicholas Evans, an expert neonatologist, told the inquest on Friday that Baby DH’s complex heart abnormalities would have been “readily detectable” in a routine pregnancy scan. He also described that scan as “a ‘missed opportunity’”.

Paul Brooks said it was “highly likely” all of Baby DH’s abnormalities would have been identified in a routine scan before birth. He said the scan would have shown that Baby DH needed to be born at a major hospital with cardiac surgery capabilities. Brooks added: “The site of [Baby DH’s] birth meant that he didn’t have a chance.”

Baby D and twins

The inquest also heard about Baby D, a stillborn second twin. Baby D’s mother did not know she was carrying twins, and Evans said the root cause of the death was that the twin pregnancy was not known before the births.

Evans said: “If [twins] had been diagnosed, at 18 weeks, as it would usually in pregnancy, there would have been very close monitoring.” He said Baby D might have survived if someone able to do advanced resuscitation had arrived in under 10 minutes.

- Advertisement -

Baby R and Baby B

Baby R likely died of severe post-maturity after being born at 43 weeks and one day in a free birth. The standard is to induce birth or perform a caesarean section at 42 weeks. The mother of Baby R had an ultrasound at 12 weeks that put the date of birth at 28 July, 2020.

The inquest concerns four babies, including Baby B, who died between 2022 and 2024 in the northern rivers region. The evidence heard on Friday points to a recurring pattern: when routine scans, dating checks and follow-up did not happen, the babies missed the care that might have identified danger earlier.

Sita Tara Kali, who described herself as a birth keeper, was part of the free birth surrounding Baby DH. The doula denied many of the parents’ claims and denied that she gave them any clinical advice, leaving the inquest to test what role each adult played in the moments before each death.

Advertisement
TAGGED:
Share This Article
Investigative news reporter specialising in local government, public policy, and social issues. Two-time Regional Press Award winner.