Cory Wilson leads 5th Circuit Proxy Voting Ruling against House proxy votes

The 5th Circuit proxy voting ruling voids House proxy voting under the Quorum Clause and could broaden challenges to the fiscal 2023 spending package.

Published
2 Min Read
Cory Wilson leads 5th Circuit Proxy Voting Ruling against House proxy votes

The Fifth Circuit’s 5th Circuit proxy voting ruling said the US House of Representatives violated the Constitution when it used proxy voting to pass a spending package during the Covid-19 pandemic. The en banc court in New Orleans said the remote-voting practice failed the Quorum Clause and sent a case that had already split judges toward the US Supreme Court.

- Advertisement -

Judge Cory Wilson wrote for the majority that the Constitution’s "text, context, original understanding, and unbroken historical application" "all indicate that Members of Congress must be present for quorum purposes—as the Supreme Court expressly held over 125 years ago, and as Congress has done ever since the Founding." He added: "Proxy presence does not count," and said the clause’s limits "cannot be circumvented by congressional fiat."

Cory Wilson and James Graves Jr.

The ruling was limited, for now, to Texas’ challenge to a federal law requiring accommodations for pregnant employees. Wilson said that limitation means the decision does not automatically erase every provision in the fiscal 2023 spending package, but it does leave room for new attacks on laws enacted in that bill.

James “Wes” Hendrix, a US District Judge, ruled in 2024 in favor of Texas’ challenge to the Pregnant Workers Fairness Act, a decision that sits inside the same litigation path. The case, State of Texas v. Blanche, reached the full court after a Fifth Circuit panel had later found that Congress acted within its authority when it created the proxy-voting rule, then saw that ruling vacated when the full court agreed to rehear the dispute.

Speech or Debate clause

Other federal courts had rejected proxy-voting challenges when the rule was adopted, saying those cases were barred by the Speech or Debate clause. During arguments in May, conservative members of the Fifth Circuit sounded doubtful of the Justice Department’s defense and pointed instead to the Constitution’s quorum clause, which gives Congress the power to compel absent members to attend.

- Advertisement -

Judge James Graves Jr. dissented, saying there was no explanation for why the court’s judgment should be limited to one part of a multi-trillion dollar bill if the entire statute had been passed unconstitutionally. The dispute now moves toward the US Supreme Court, where the ruling is certain to be tested and where its reach beyond the Texas challenge will be the next issue for lawmakers and litigants watching the fiscal 2023 spending package.

Advertisement
Share This Article
On-the-ground news correspondent reporting from city halls, courtrooms, and press briefings. Holder of a Columbia Journalism School degree.