Tristan Buckmaster closes OpenAI loophole in Navier–stokes Equations proof

Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge say they closed a loophole in OpenAI’s Navier–Stokes equations proof with a new AI-aided write-up posted this morning.

Published
2 Min Read
Tristan Buckmaster closes OpenAI loophole in Navier–stokes Equations proof

Tristan Buckmaster and Levent Alpöge say they have closed a loophole in OpenAI’s September proof of the Navier–Stokes equations with a new AI-aided write-up posted this morning. The dispute now turns on whether the earlier result really met the challenge conditions for the $1-million prize.

- Advertisement -

Buckmaster posted the dense proof on Mastodon at 8:37 A.M. EST. He said the write-up was unpolished because he and Alpöge could not risk waiting, and he tied that urgency to “after last time.”

Tristan Buckmaster at New York University

Buckmaster is a New York University professor. He said OpenAI tried to scoop his and Alpöge’s progress, and he publicly suspected that OpenAI stole his user data in the race to get there first.

That is the practical shift for readers following the math fight. The argument is no longer just about whether a proof exists, but about whether the proof addresses the actual Navier-Stokes problem instead of a narrower setup built around a specially chosen force.

OpenAI and the forcing loophole

OpenAI announced in September that it had proved the Navier-Stokes equations blow up, and the September OpenAI solution technically satisfied the conditions for the Clay Mathematics Institute’s $1-million prize. Many experts still judged it unsatisfying because it relied on an unrealistic, finely tuned force that stirs the liquid in just the right way to produce infinite velocity.

- Advertisement -

That distinction matters because the Navier-Stokes equations date back to the early- to mid-19th century and model how fluids swirl and eddy. A proof that leans on an artificial forcing trick can satisfy a formal check while leaving the core challenge open in substance.

AI and the certificate

Levent Alpöge works at Anthropic. He and Buckmaster did not release the certificate of the result in the rush, and the report said it would be released soon.

For now, the unresolved issue is the certificate itself. Until that appears, readers following the Navier-Stokes problem have the new claim, the old loophole, and a proof that still needs its final paper trail.

Advertisement
Share This Article
Technology journalist focused on accessibility, diversity in STEM, and the human impact of emerging technologies. TED fellow.