E.J. Carroll died suddenly on November 19 at age 66. Jon Mason of Mason-Lewis Entertainment said he was on his way to a voice-over booking when he died.
Jon Mason on Carroll
“E.J. Carroll was a consummate actor known and loved for his intense commitment to the characters he played,” Mason said. “There isn’t an actor in New York that hadn’t worked with or crossed paths with E.J., known for stealing scenes alongside Robert De Niro, Mickey Rourke, Bruce Dern and most recently Jalen Brunson and Quinta Brunson.”
He added, “He will be greatly missed by the acting community which he lived for.” Those lines fit the career Carroll built across nearly three decades: one that moved from NBC’s Law & Order in 1998 to recurring and guest work across television and film, plus a voice role in Grand Theft Auto V.
Law & Order to The Deuce
Carroll’s first screen credit came in 1998, when he played a cop in Law & Order. He returned for three other episodes through 2004, then appeared in two early-2000s episodes of Law & Order: SVU and two Law & Order: Criminal Intent episodes during that decade.
In 2007, he played Dr. Scott in The Rocky Horror Tribute Show, which ran one night as a benefit for cancer charities Acting for a Cure and Komen for the Cure. He later appeared in Darren Aronofsky’s The Wrestler in 2009, then played Sheriff Victor Sickles in two 2012 episodes of Boardwalk Empire and also appeared in Damages that same year.
Fat Mooney and beyond
Carroll went on to guest on The Blacklist, Blue Bloods, High Maintenance, Pose and The Punisher. In 2017, he recurred on The Deuce as Fat Mooney and appeared in a half-dozen episodes, a steadier run than most of his earlier television work.
He also filmed a role in A Delicate Arrangement and voiced a character in Grand Theft Auto V. That mix of credits explains why Mason’s tribute lands as more than a courtesy note: Carroll worked across franchises, formats and audiences, and his death removes a reliable character actor from New York’s acting circle.
The immediate unanswered question is the cause of his sudden death, which Mason did not give. For now, the clearest fact is the simplest one: Carroll died while heading to work, and the industry he moved through for nearly three decades has lost a familiar face.







