Judge Debra McCaslin denied Alex Murdaugh’s motion to dismiss the indictment against him on Friday, keeping the charges in place as he heads toward a retrial next year. The ruling leaves intact the murder case tied to the 2021 killings of Margaret "Maggie" Murdaugh and Paul Murdaugh.
McCaslin wrote that the defense had not shown any "intentional prosecutorial or investigative misconduct" that would undermine the grand jury proceedings. She also said "the remaining unchallenged evidence overwhelmingly established probable cause," preserving the indictments even after the defense attack on how they were obtained.
Alex Murdaugh indictment ruling
The challenge centered on testimony presented to the Colleton County grand jury. Defense attorney Jim Griffin said the indictments rested on false testimony from David Owen, then the lead state investigator, about blood spatter on Murdaugh’s shirt and ammunition found on the family's property.
Griffin said Owen told the grand jury there was blood spatter on Murdaugh’s shirt on the night of the killings when there was none. He also said Owen inaccurately described guns found on the property as loaded in the same way as the ammunition used to kill Paul.
McCaslin rejected that argument. Her order said the record did not show fabricated evidence or that "false testimony was knowingly presented to the grand jury."
Friday in Colleton County
The judge’s decision followed the South Carolina Supreme Court’s earlier overturning of Murdaugh’s 2023 murder convictions because of jury interference. That reversal sent the case back into the criminal process, where the indictment challenge became a gatekeeping issue before any retrial could move ahead.
Margaret "Maggie" Murdaugh was 52 and Paul was 22 when they were found dead from multiple gunshot wounds at the family's hunting estate in 2021. Prosecutor Creighton Waters said the grand jury would have heard much more compelling evidence, and he pointed to a video found on Paul’s cell phone that he said captured Paul, Maggie and Alex Murdaugh together just moments before the killings.
Owen testified at trial that he told the grand jury an expert found multiple particles of blood spatter on Murdaugh’s shirt and that he had not seen a report finding no human blood on the shirt until after the indictment. He also said he had inaccurately described other firearms at the property as loaded similarly to the shotgun used to kill Paul, adding, "He said he wasn't trying to trick grand jurors."
The ruling keeps the indictment standing as the retrial approaches, and the dispute now turns from the grand jury process to what evidence the prosecution will place before jurors next year. The defense has already said the grand jury record was distorted; McCaslin’s order says the disputed testimony did not erase probable cause.
Justice Department seeks Cassidy Hutchinson indictment, Comey seeks dismissal in James Comey indictment, and Richard Pridgen murder charge indictment show how indictment fights can shape the next stage of a case before trial.







