Twickenham's Swing Low response to the haka is the least imaginative part of Wales Vs Australia Rugby

Wales vs Australia rugby heads to Twickenham with England fans poised to drown out the haka again with Swing Low, Sweet Chariot.

Published
2 Min Read
Twickenham's Swing Low response to the haka is the least imaginative part of Wales Vs Australia Rugby

The haka is supposed to set the tone, but at Twickenham the real pre-match ritual now risks being the crowd trying to shout it down. Ahead of Wales vs Australia rugby, England fans appear determined to answer the haka with Swing Low, Sweet Chariot, and that tells you almost everything you need to know about how quickly a supposedly stirring tradition can tip into routine.

- Advertisement -

Oliver Brown was right to call it uninspired and witless. There is nothing especially daring about piling one chant on top of another, least of all when the whole point of the moment is supposed to be respect, theatre and a little bit of tension before the rugby begins. If you want evidence that this habit has been growing for a while, last year at Twickenham the Swing Low chanting drowned out Codie Taylor’s war cries. That is not atmosphere. That is noise for noise’s sake.

From Cardiff's Dragon’s breath to Twickenham’s familiar chorus

The contrast is hard to ignore. In Cardiff, Wales responded to the haka with Dragon’s breath, a spectacle that was worked on by Alex Luff and his team a year before the event. It was theatrical, deliberate and memorable enough to rack up 1.1 million hits on YouTube in six days. That is not just a neat number; it is proof that audiences know the difference between something inventive and something phoned in.

The Wales effort even connected with the wider lore of the occasion. In Yokohama at the 2019 World Cup semi-final, England used a flying V formation before the haka, and whether you loved it or rolled your eyes, at least it tried to create a moment. By comparison, the current mood at Twickenham feels less like invention and more like reflex. Swing Low, Sweet Chariot has become the default answer, as if repetition alone makes it meaningful.

None of this means the match itself loses its edge. Wales vs Australia rugby still has the proper stakes of an international fixture at Twickenham, and the haka will still demand attention for its two minutes. But that is the point: the ritual is brief, the rest of the day is long, and the smartest crowd understands that less can be more. Instead, the temptation is always to drown it out, to make the point as loudly as possible, and to confuse volume with imagination.

- Advertisement -

There is a difference between a venue finding its voice and a crowd simply reaching for the same old chorus. Twickenham appears set to do the latter again, and if that happens, it will only underline how much more interesting Cardiff’s response was. Sometimes the most revealing thing in sport is not what a crowd shouts, but how little it has left to say.

Advertisement
Share This Article
Sports writer with 9 years on the NFL and NBA beat. Sideline reporter and credentialed press member at three Super Bowls.