Stephen Timms is expected to publish the final review into Pip as soon as Tuesday, advancing the UK welfare system big reset with a plan to overhaul the benefit rather than scrap it for people under 25. The review would keep Pip in place for all ages, a direct answer to the competing plan put forward by Alan Milburn.
That split matters because about 90% of the Pip caseload is made up of people over 25. Milburn’s report called for Pip to be removed for adults under 25 and replaced by an additional cost allowance, a change that would cut £3.6bn from spending on young people.
Timms, Farquharson and Brennan
The review was led by Timms, who serves as social security minister, and shaped by a steering group co-chaired by Clenton Farquharson and Sharon Brennan. Most of the Timms review’s 12 members have lived experience of disability or long-term health conditions, giving the process a direct line to the people who use Pip.
In July, the interim report described Pip as widely valued but no longer fit for purpose. Further emerging findings in September went further, saying Pip was unfit for purpose and that a major overhaul was needed. The final report is expected to turn that into a set of recommendations ministers can act on before legislation is written next year.
Milburn’s under-25 proposal
The competing review by Milburn took the opposite route. It would scrap Pip for adults under 25 and replace it with an additional cost allowance, a narrower system that would shift the support structure for younger claimants while leaving older claimants outside the proposed cut.
Government officials have said the Timms process began before Milburn’s review was commissioned, and ministers now face two sharply different designs. One keeps the existing benefit across age groups and overhauls how it works; the other removes it from adults under 25 and redirects spending into a new allowance.
Labour’s Pip reset
The backdrop is the collapse of earlier Pip changes under Keir Starmer in 2025 after a major rebellion by Labour MPs. Those plans were built around £5bn in cuts, and the retreat left ministers seeking a new framework that could hold up politically and survive contact with the review process.
For disabled claimants, the immediate next step is the publication of Timms’s recommendations and the ministerial decision that follows. The choice now is whether to adopt a broad overhaul of Pip for all ages or move toward age-based change that would pull younger adults out of the current system.







