Review: Ryan Murphy’s ‘Monster: The Ed Gein Story’ Fails to Impress

Ryan Murphy’s latest addition to the True Crime anthology series, entitled “Monster: The Ed Gein Story,” has stirred debate since its release. While the series has previously tackled infamous figures like Jeffrey Dahmer and the Menendez brothers, this installment focuses on Ed Gein, a notorious criminal who gained infamy for his gruesome acts in Plainfield, Wisconsin.

The Life of Ed Gein

Ed Gein is not as widely known as other serial killers such as Ted Bundy or John Wayne Gacy. However, his horrific activities, including grave robbing and murder, have left a lasting impact on popular culture. Gein was responsible for the deaths of two confirmed victims, but his exhumation of female corpses and the use of body parts in various domestic items make his legacy particularly chilling.

Key Elements of the Series

• Structure: The series employs a dual timeline, oscillating between Gein’s past crimes and the present-day reactions to his life.
• Character Portrayal: Actor Charlie Hunnam takes on the role of Ed Gein, showcasing his troubled relationship with his mother and his disturbing fascinations.
• Cultural References: The narrative connects Gein’s influence to iconic horror films, notably Alfred Hitchcock’s adaptation of Robert Bloch’s novel inspired by Gein.

Criticism and Evaluation

The series has received mixed reviews, with some praising its pacing and clever storytelling. However, many critics argue that it lacks moral depth. Viewers are presented with meticulous depictions of Gein’s abhorrent acts and a significant emphasis on the Nazi atrocities intertwined with his story.

Lack of Moral Commentary

Critics highlight that the production fails to provide a substantial commentary on Gein’s psyche or the societal factors contributing to his actions. While it touches on themes of obsession and mental health, the intricacies of his character are oversimplified, reducing him to a mere victim of circumstance.

Conclusion

Ultimately, “Monster: The Ed Gein Story” may resonate with audiences drawn to horror and true crime, but it raises questions about the ethical implications of glamorizing such a figure. The show might excel in its visual storytelling but falls short in offering a profound exploration of its subject matter. For those looking for a deeper understanding of true crime phenomena, this series may not deliver the insights expected from Ryan Murphy’s productions.