Rockies Aim for Fresh Start at Third Base Post Ryan McMahon Trade

The Colorado Rockies are navigating a significant transition after trading their All-Star third baseman, Ryan McMahon, as they aim for a fresh start at third base. This trade has left a notable gap in their roster, particularly as they approach the 2026 season.

Impact of McMahon’s Trade

Ryan McMahon, an All-Star in 2024, began the 2025 season slowly, posting a batting line of .217/.314/.403 over 100 games. He managed to hit 16 home runs, gather 35 RBIs, and score 42 runs. Despite possessing power, his performance was marred by strikeout issues and a significant drop in his batting average.

The Rockies decided to trade McMahon, believing that the potential return would be more beneficial than the current output from the veteran player. This decision, however, has created a pressing need at the third base position, leaving Colorado with limited options for the immediately upcoming season.

Current Depth Chart at Third Base

Besides McMahon, the Rockies have seen several players fill in at third base this season:

• Kyle Karros
• Orlando Arcia
• Kyle Farmer (9 games)
• Warming Bernabel (2 games)
• Aaron Schunk (2 games)
• Tyler Freeman (1 game)
• Owen Miller (1 game)

The Rockies’ third basemen collectively logged the second-highest strikeout percentage, the seventh-lowest batting average, and the sixth-lowest weighted runs created plus (wRC+) in the league. This poor performance raises concerns for 2026, particularly as the team evaluates who can effectively fill the hot corner.

Future Prospects and Options

One of the brighter prospects in the Rockies’ minor league system is Ethan Hedges, a third-round pick from USC. However, he faced challenges in his first professional season, hitting just .195/.303/.234 in High-A. His development will take time, indicating Colorado needs a short-term solution at third base.

As the Rockies look to bolster their roster, it is crucial for the new general manager to prioritize filling this gap. While star free agents like Alex Bregman and Eugenio Suarez may be unlikely to join the franchise, there are several players who could provide immediate support for the team.

Conclusion

The Rockies must act swiftly to address their challenge at third base. With limited options internally and a crucial position that influences both the offense and defense, strategic decision-making will be paramount as they prepare for the future.