Strictly Fans Outraged by Judge’s ‘Jail-Worthy’ Score for Karen Carney
Controversy erupted among fans of El-Balad’s “Strictly Come Dancing” when judge Craig Revel Horwood awarded a low score to contestant Karen Carney. Carney, 38, performed with partner Carlos Gu during the show’s “Movie Week” on October 11, 2023. The theme inspired couples to dance to iconic film soundtracks.
Carney and Gu danced the Cha Cha to “She’s A Lady” by Tom Jones, a song from the 2000 film “Miss Congeniality”. While the judges generally praised Carney’s transformation into the character played by Sandra Bullock, Horwood’s score of just four points generated outrage among viewers.
Audience Reaction to Low Score
The remaining judges—Shirley Ballas, Motsi Mabuse, and Anton DuBeke—awarded the couple seven points each, resulting in a total score of 25. Fans expressed their disbelief and anger across social media platforms.
- One viewer remarked, “A 4 from Craig really? So ridiculous.”
- Another took to social media to say they were “FLABBERGASTED” by the decision.
- Many labeled the score as “foolish” and even “jail-worthy.”
Comparisons were drawn to fellow competitor Ross King, who also received a four from Horwood. Fans felt Carney’s performance deserved a higher score, with one stating, “Karen deserved at least a 6 from Craig.”
Other Developments in the Show
In another twist, Neighbours star Stefan Dennis was absent from the live show after medical advice to rest. He and partner Dianne Buswell automatically move on to the next stage of the competition despite the absence. Earlier that day, Buswell addressed claims regarding her partner’s health and her own pregnancy on Instagram, clarifying she was capable of performing.
“We wouldn’t lie, especially about someone being sick,” she stated. Buswell made history as the first contestant to compete on “Strictly” while pregnant and emphasized that contingency plans are in place should any professional dancers need medical attention.
Overall, the reactions to Horwood’s controversial score reflect the passionate engagement of “Strictly Come Dancing” fans and underline the stakes involved in reality TV competitions.
