Top New Netflix Shows Scoring 90%+ on Rotten Tomatoes (October 2025)

Netflix continues to deliver exceptional content, with three shows earning a prestigious score of over 90 percent on Rotten Tomatoes. These series, notable for their critical acclaim, include two original productions and one from AMC.

Top New Netflix Shows Scoring 90%+ on Rotten Tomatoes

The Diplomat

One standout in the lineup is The Diplomat, boasting a 90 percent rating. Since its debut in 2023, this political thriller has captivated audiences every year with new seasons. The series stars Keri Russell as Kate Wyler, the American ambassador to the United Kingdom.

In the latest season, Kate navigates a complex international crisis, all while her political influence grows beyond that of her husband, Hal Wyler (played by Rufus Sewell). Season 3 is set to premiere on October 16. The first two seasons are already available to stream on Netflix.

Nobody Wants This

Nobody Wants This ranks even higher, achieving a remarkable 95 percent on Rotten Tomatoes. This romantic comedy series, which premiered in September 2024, features Kristen Bell as Joanne Williams and Adam Brody as Noah Roklov.

The unlikely pair navigates their relationship amidst differing beliefs, with Joanne being an agnostic podcaster and Noah a devoted rabbi. Season 2 is scheduled to begin filming soon and is set to premiere on October 23, just over a year after its successful first season. The first season is currently available on Netflix.

Dark Winds

Dark Winds, another gem in this collection, proudly holds a perfect 100 percent rating. This noir thriller, which takes place in the 1970s, focuses on tribal police lieutenant Joe Leaphorn, portrayed by Zahn McClarnon, and FBI agent Jim Chee, played by Kiowa Gordon.

With its unique setting in the Four Corners region, the show has garnered critical acclaim since its debut in 2022. Season 3 is expected to arrive on October 27, following its earlier premiere on AMC. Seasons 1 and 2 can be found streaming on Netflix.

• The Diplomat – 90% rating, Season 3 premieres on October 16
• Nobody Wants This – 95% rating, Season 2 premieres on October 23
• Dark Winds – 100% rating, Season 3 premieres on October 27

These acclaimed shows highlight Netflix’s commitment to quality storytelling and engaging content. With impressive ratings and compelling plots, they continue to attract audiences, making them must-watch series this October.