Choosing Between J.J. McCarthy and Carson Wentz for Vikings QB Role
The Minnesota Vikings’ quarterback situation remains a significant topic of discussion as the team prepares for their upcoming game against the Philadelphia Eagles. A pivotal decision looms over head coach Kevin O’Connell: who will lead the team on Sunday, J.J. McCarthy or Carson Wentz?
Injury Reports and Decision Timeline
After returning from a European trip and their bye week, fans are eager to know the starting quarterback. O’Connell has been noncommittal, hinting that a decision might already be made but will be kept under wraps for now.
McCarthy’s progress from a high ankle sprain, sustained in Week 2 against the Atlanta Falcons, is closely monitored. The typical recovery timeframe for this type of injury is four to six weeks. This marks the fifth week since McCarthy’s injury, leading to speculation about his availability.
Comparing the Quarterbacks
- J.J. McCarthy: Known for his potential, McCarthy’s return hinges on his health. His ability to execute footwork and mechanics will be crucial upon his return.
- Carson Wentz: Wentz has played admirably in McCarthy’s absence, showing a relatively average performance level overall.
While McCarthy is still recovering, O’Connell’s deliberate ambiguity gives rise to uncertainty about the team’s confidence in him. The media scrutiny surrounding the situation adds pressure on the coach, as clarity is often muddled by brief soundbites rather than full press conference content.
Previous QB Decisions
The Vikings have faced similar scenarios previously, where decisions on quarterbacks remained unclear during critical periods. Reports surfaced regarding potential interest in other quarterbacks like Sam Darnold and Daniel Jones, but no significant moves materialized.
Statistical Performance
In analyzing their play, Wentz has started three games, while McCarthy has started two. However, McCarthy’s playing time has been limited, resulting in fewer dropbacks compared to Wentz.
- J.J. McCarthy: Struggled statistically, holding the worst EPA/play among QBs with 60 or more dropbacks.
- Carson Wentz: Performed better statistically, producing at an average QB level, leading to a 2-1 record during his starts.
Offensive Strategy Changes
Under O’Connell, the Vikings’ game plan has distinctly shifted between the two quarterbacks. With McCarthy, the offense relied heavily on play-action, which was called on over one-third of his dropbacks. In contrast, Wentz’s play percentage for similar strategies dropped considerably.
Conclusion: Who Will Start?
Despite McCarthy’s medical status indicating potential readiness, O’Connell’s reticence to confirm a starter allows for much speculation in the media. Ultimately, the team’s upcoming choice between J.J. McCarthy and Carson Wentz for the starting quarterback role will be a critical moment for the Vikings as they prepare for their game against the Eagles.
