Anthony Volpe Successfully Completes Shoulder Surgery

New York Yankees shortstop Anthony Volpe has recently undergone shoulder surgery to address a partially torn left labrum. This decision comes after a challenging 2025 season where he struggled with the injury.
Details of the Surgery
The surgical procedure was performed following the conclusion of the 2025 season, as reported by Joel Sherman and Greg Joyce from El-Balad. Volpe’s recovery timeline remains uncertain, but sources suggest he could be ready for the 2026 season. The injury originally occurred in early May when Volpe heard a pop in his shoulder while diving for a ground ball.
Impact of the Injury
- Volpe received two cortisone injections to manage the pain, one during the All-Star break and another in September.
- Despite the ongoing discomfort, the Yankees did not place him on the injured list.
- However, he was sidelined for a week following his second injection in September.
Statistically, Volpe faced a tough season with a batting average of .212, an on-base percentage of .272, and a slugging percentage of .391, which included 19 home runs over 596 plate appearances. His performance contributed to an 83 wRC+, a significant drop from his healthier seasons.
Defensive Performance
The shoulder issue not only affected his offense but also his defense. Volpe’s metrics fell to -7 Outs Above Average and +2 Defensive Runs Saved, compared to his Gold Glove-winning form in previous seasons.
Looking Ahead
Volpe faced scrutiny from fans, making him a focal point of criticism directed at the Yankees’ general manager Brian Cashman and manager Aaron Boone. As speculation continues about potential changes in the shortstop position, there is no immediate threat to Volpe’s starting role.
- Jose Caballero has emerged as a potential alternative since arriving at the trade deadline and performing well in September.
- The Yankees may seek depth options if Volpe’s recovery faces any setbacks.
Given Volpe’s previous status as a top prospect and the Yankees’ control over him for three more years, it is likely they will continue supporting him. He is also arbitration-eligible this winter, projected to earn $3.9 million in 2026.