Should the Browns Trade Myles Garrett Now?

The upcoming trade deadline on November 4 has sparked discussions about potential player movements, particularly involving Myles Garrett of the Cleveland Browns. Despite speculation, the team has maintained a firm stance against trading him, citing his invaluable skills as he leads the NFL with ten sacks this season. However, discussions around Garrett’s future may be essential for the Browns as they reassess their rebuilding strategy.

Should the Browns Trade Myles Garrett Now?

Myles Garrett’s performance has been exceptional, with a career-high of five sacks recorded against the New England Patriots last week. Despite his individual success, the Browns face significant challenges, especially with their aging core that previously contributed to playoff runs in 2020 and 2023. Players like Denzel Ward and Joel Bitonio are nearing the end of their primes, and the team lacks depth at quarterback, receiver, and tackle.

Cleveland’s Transition and Future Prospects

The Browns have dealt with three first-round picks lost in the Deshaun Watson trade, which has impacted their roster replenishment. They acknowledged their need for rejuvenation by trading their second-round pick earlier this year. The team identified its necessity for youth, as evidenced by the promising performance of rookies like Mason Graham and Carson Schwesinger.

• Potential Trade Scenario: If the Browns could trade Garrett for two first-round picks, a second-round pick in 2026, and a third-round pick in 2027, this would significantly boost their draft capital.
• This would provide Cleveland three first-round picks and two second-rounders in 2026, along with a total of ten picks across the first five rounds over two years.

Such a strategic move could accelerate the Browns’ timeline for competing again, potentially setting them to be formidable by 2027 or 2028. This perspective draws parallels to the New England Patriots, who are experiencing a revitalization thanks to quarterback Drake Maye, now in his second year.

The Value of Timing in Trades

As Garrett approaches age 32 in December 2027, his trade value may decline. Historical trade moves involving players like Von Miller and J.J. Watt illustrate how player value can diminish over time. The current season poses a unique opportunity for the Browns to capitalize on Garrett’s current market value before it wanes.

Garrett holds a manageable contract, with only $73.2 million owed over the next two years, making him an appealing target for teams looking to bolster their defenses.

Future Considerations for the Browns

Although trading Garrett may seem like a difficult decision, it could offer a substantial return during a potentially lost season. The Cleveland Browns are at a crossroads, much like the Seattle Seahawks three years ago when they traded Russell Wilson, setting up a strong roster for future success.

Ultimately, the decision regarding Myles Garrett will impact the Browns’ direction. As they weigh their options, focusing on what benefits the long-term vision of the franchise should take precedence over immediate concerns.