Review: “Death by Lightning” Unveils Shocking Insights on President Garfield
“Death by Lightning” premieres on Netflix, shedding light on the intriguing story of President James A. Garfield and his assassin, Charles Guiteau. This new docudrama offers a combination of historical insight and contemporary themes, such as civil rights, income inequality, and the dangers of political cronyism. Garfield, who served only 200 days in office, is portrayed as a tragic figure whose potential as a leader was unexplored due to his untimely assassination.
Key Themes and Historical Context
The narrative, drawn from Candice Millard’s book “Destiny of the Republic” and its accompanying documentary, illustrates Garfield’s commitment to addressing America’s pressing issues. His inaugural speech underscored the ongoing oppression faced by Black citizens, making this part of his story particularly relevant today.
Garfield’s Political Journey
- Drafted during the 1880 Republican National Convention.
- Delivered a stirring speech nominating Treasury Secretary John Sherman.
- Regarded as humble and self-effacing, without a personal agenda.
Despite his reluctance, Garfield accepted the presidency, seeing it as an opportunity to enact change. His campaign included public engagements, with up to 50,000 attendees at one rally in New York’s Madison Square Park.
The Role of Charles Guiteau
In stark contrast, Guiteau is depicted as a drifter with delusions of grandeur. Believing he played a critical role in Garfield’s election, he became enraged when he was not appointed ambassador to France. His mental state deteriorated, leading him down a path to murder.
Prime Characters and Cast
The miniseries excels in its casting choices, featuring:
- Michael Shannon as James A. Garfield, embodying a blend of kindness and gravity.
- Matthew Macfadyen as Charles Guiteau, portraying the tortured emotions of a misguided assassin.
- Betty Gilpin as Crete Garfield, displaying political insight and strong opinions.
- Shea Whigham as Roscoe Conkling, presenting Garfield’s political antagonist.
- Nick Offerman as Chester A. Arthur, whose character undergoes significant development.
Production Quality
The production captures the essence of the late 19th century with impressive sets and authentic period detail. Historical events, such as the 1880 convention in Chicago, are recreated with fidelity, immersing viewers in the political climate of the time.
Conclusion: An Emotional Portrait
“Death by Lightning” is a poignant exploration of the intersecting lives of Garfield and Guiteau. The series does not shy away from the emotional toll of Garfield’s assassination, illustrating the confusion and turmoil of that period. As viewers witness Garfield’s gradual decline, the series cultivates a sense of longing for what might have been.
In tackling the complexities of political ambition, mental illness, and historical tragedy, this docudrama adds a valuable chapter to the narrative of American history.
