Netflix’s “Death by Lightning” Illuminates a Brief, Impactful Presidency

The new Netflix miniseries titled “Death by Lightning” shines a light on a significant yet brief period in American history. It focuses on James A. Garfield, the 20th President of the United States, and his assassin, Charles Guiteau. As narrated, Garfield’s presidency lasted a mere six months, ending with his death from a gunshot wound before he reached 50. This series emphasizes the contrasting lives and ambitions of these two historical figures.

Garfield: The Forgotten President

Garfield entered the political scene as a surprising candidate in the 1880 election. Despite facing immense challenges, he aimed to usher in progressivism during a tumultuous post-Civil War era characterized by corruption and political chaos. Understood as a fundamentally decent man, Garfield’s storyline explores his genuine desire to unify a fractured nation while navigating the powerful machines of politics.

Guiteau: The Delusional Assassin

In stark contrast, the character of Charles Guiteau is portrayed as a troubled individual fueled by grandiosity and disillusionment. Guiteau, originally a supporter of Garfield, succumbs to a series of misguided rationalizations which lead him to commit assassination. His tumultuous backstory, including his failure to secure a diplomatic position, showcases the psychological complexities that drive him to violence.

Creative Team and Performances

Directed by Matt Ross and created by Mike Makowsky, “Death by Lightning” adapts Candice Millard’s historical works into a compelling narrative. The series features outstanding performances from:

• Michael Shannon as James A. Garfield
• Matthew Macfadyen as Charles Guiteau
• Betty Gilpin as Lucretia Garfield
• Nick Offerman as Chester A. Arthur
• Bradley Whitford as James Blaine
• Shea Whigham as Roscoe Conkling

Shannon’s portrayal of Garfield captures both his decency and underlying ambitions. Macfadyen’s Guiteau, while delusional, evokes sympathy; his character arc reveals a pitiable fool manipulated by larger societal forces.

Critical Reception and Themes

Critics have highlighted the series for its brisk pacing and focus on historical detail. The interplay of Garfield’s progressive ideals against the backdrop of political corruption resonates throughout the four episodes. Notably, the series cleverly depicts the political machinations of the time, including blackmail and backdoor deals.

The narrative leaves viewers wondering about the potential reforms Garfield might have implemented had he survived. “Death by Lightning” serves as both a historical exploration and a commentary on the political climate, drawing parallels to contemporary issues.

As a captivating mix of history and drama, “Death by Lightning” invites audiences to reexamine a forgotten chapter in American history when it premieres on November 6.