Ex-NFL Executive Praises Mike McDaniel as Elite, Criticizes Dolphins
Mike McDaniel’s tenure as head coach of the Miami Dolphins is currently under scrutiny. With the 2025 season ahead, fans and analysts debate his future, but the ultimate decision lies with owner Stephen Ross.
Joe Banner’s Perspective on Mike McDaniel
Former NFL executive Joe Banner recently shared his insights regarding McDaniel on “The Rich Eisen Show.” He lauded McDaniel as one of the finest offensive minds in the league, drawing comparisons to renowned coaches like Andy Reid.
Concerns About Ownership
Banner provided critical observations about Stephen Ross’s leadership. He argued that the owner’s primary responsibility is to ensure the team’s success from a fan’s perspective. However, Banner believes Ross often prioritizes brand development over the team’s competitive performance.
- Banner’s Analysis: McDaniel excels in offensive strategy but faces challenges as a head coach.
- Ross’s Focus: More on brand than on team success.
Future Challenges for the Dolphins
Banner expressed doubts about McDaniel’s long-term viability in Miami. He suggested that, should McDaniel be replaced, he would likely find success as an offensive coordinator with another team. The Dolphins are unable to revert McDaniel’s role and may lose his talent entirely.
Organizational Issues Under Ross
Addressing broader issues, Banner highlighted that the Dolphins need effective leadership across all levels. He criticized the prolonged tenure of general manager Chris Grier, attributing several draft failures and poor coaching decisions to him.
- Grier’s faults: Draft blunders and inconsistent coaching hires.
- Leadership void: Lack of a proficient head coach and strong general manager.
Since Ross took ownership in 2009, the Dolphins have failed to establish a winning culture. Banner pointed out that the team has gone through numerous roster changes without apparent strategy, begging the question of their overall direction.
The Path Forward
According to Banner, the next offseason is pivotal. Without an overhaul of leadership, including a new head coach and general manager, the Dolphins risk continued mediocrity. Stephen Ross must venture beyond his comfort zone to revitalize the organization, or the team will stagnate further.
