Expert: Only One Liverpool Signing Would Make City’s Starting XI
Liverpool FC has made significant changes to its squad, investing over £450 million in the summer transfer window for the 2025-26 season. This investment has led to heightened expectations among fans for immediate success. However, recent performances suggest a period of adjustment is still ongoing.
Walcott’s Assessment of Liverpool and Manchester City
Former Arsenal player Theo Walcott has voiced his opinions on the comparison between Liverpool’s new recruits and Manchester City’s established players. On the “It’s Called Soccer Podcast,” he stated that only one Liverpool signing, Alexander Isak, would be worthy of a spot in a combined Liverpool-Manchester City XI. This assertion has prompted discussions among supporters of both clubs.
Walcott’s Combined XI
Walcott’s selection excluded several Liverpool newcomers but highlighted Isak’s potential. His proposed lineup included:
- Gianluigi Donnarumma (GK)
- Dominik Szoboszlai
- John Stones
- Virgil van Dijk
- Andrew Robertson
- Rodri
- Ryan Gravenberch
- Phil Foden
- Mohamed Salah
- Erling Haaland
- Alexander Isak
Despite Hugo Ekitike’s early impact at Liverpool, Walcott emphasized the need for consistency and proven performance. His omission of Ekitike from the combined XI sparked discussions about player performance under pressure.
Managerial Adjustments Ahead of Man City Clash
Under the management of Arne Slot, Liverpool faced challenges this season, particularly in midfield. However, returning to a familiar midfield trio has yielded improved results, including a recent 1-0 victory over Real Madrid in the Champions League.
Liverpool fans are now optimistic as the team gears up to face Manchester City, benefiting from better cohesion and form. But discussions about how Liverpool’s squad compares to Pep Guardiola’s established side remain prevalent, highlighted by comments from City star Erling Haaland about the ongoing battle.
Who’s Leading the Line for Liverpool?
Selection dilemmas continue for Liverpool as Isak and Ekitike compete for the striker position. Both players bring unique qualities: Isak’s finishing and Ekitike’s movement. Injuries have affected Isak’s consistency, allowing Ekitike to shine. Slot might consider adjustments to his attacking setup, potentially deploying Isak on the left flank.
This strategy could provide opportunities for both players while enhancing Liverpool’s tactical flexibility. Such an approach would not only resolve the selection issue but also strengthen their challenge against Manchester City, reaffirming the reasoning behind their significant summer investments.
