Guillermo del Toro’s ‘Frankenstein’ Falls Short Due to Creature’s Weakness

Guillermo del Toro’s latest film, “Frankenstein” (2025), has generated considerable attention since its October premiere. This adaptation of Mary Shelley’s classic tale offers a unique perspective on the age-old story of creation and monstrosity.

Film Overview

The film, now available on Netflix, stars Jacob Elordi as the Creature and Oscar Isaac as Victor Frankenstein. Del Toro’s interpretation diverges significantly from Shelley’s original narrative, focusing on themes of alienation and parental impact.

Character Developments

• Victor Frankenstein: Portrayed as a brash and ambitious man, Victor is driven by a desire to conquer death.
• The Creature: Elordi’s character is depicted as a vulnerable being, akin to an oversized toddler, reflecting deep emotional struggles.

Del Toro relocates the setting to Edinburgh, a hub of 18th-century medical knowledge, further shaping Victor’s character into a more virile and aggressive figure. Elizabeth, played by Mia Goth, serves as a complex figure, representing both Victor’s love and the echo of his lost mother.

Thematic Exploration

The film emphasizes the nuances of creation and the effects of abandonment and disappointment. Del Toro’s adaptation presents Victor as an ambitious scientist who eventually falters in his role as a creator.

While Shelley’s work presents moral ambiguity regarding the Creature’s nature, del Toro’s version simplifies these complexities. In his narrative, the Creature is innocent yet remains misunderstood by society. This approach strips the Creature of the darker aspects of his character found in the novel.

A Unique Vision

Del Toro’s “Frankenstein” stands out not only for its visual splendor but also for its emotional depth. The intricate set design enhances the storytelling, creating a vivid backdrop for the characters’ journeys. The lush textures of velvet and glass juxtaposed with the chilling narrative evoke strong emotions.

Contrasting Views on Morality

The relationship between Victor and the Creature raises questions about parental responsibility and societal rejection. In this adaptation, Victor’s actions lead to significant repercussions, transforming him into a more complex figure who grapples with his failures.

Conclusion

Guillermo del Toro’s “Frankenstein” is a visually stunning and emotionally resonant film that reflects on creation, loss, and humanity. While it offers a fresh take on a beloved story, the reduction of the Creature’s moral complexity leads to a less nuanced exploration of the themes introduced by Mary Shelley.