Judge Admits Statements in Gaudreau Brothers’ Death Trial
In a significant ruling, a New Jersey judge has determined that statements made by Sean M. Higgins, the accused in the deaths of NHL player Johnny Gaudreau and his brother Matthew, are admissible in court. Superior Court Judge Michael Silvanio’s decision came on a Monday following an October hearing. This ruling is pivotal as Higgins faces serious charges related to the tragic incident.
Details of the Case
Higgins, aged 44, has been charged with multiple offenses, including:
- Two counts of first-degree aggravated manslaughter
- Two counts of second-degree reckless vehicular homicide
- Leaving the scene of a fatal collision
The incident occurred on August 29, 2024, as the Gaudreau brothers were cycling near their family residence. This date was particularly poignant, as it was the eve of their sister’s wedding.
Judge’s Rationale for Admissibility
The ruling came after reviewing testimony from four New Jersey State Police officers and examining body-camera footage from the scene. Judge Silvanio found that Higgins was unrestrained and communicated freely with officers at the crash site. He highlighted that Higgins was able to use his cellphone and smoke a cigarette, indicating he was not under any coercion.
Defense attorneys argued against the use of Higgins’ statements, claiming he had not been properly informed of his Miranda rights. They asserted that questioning should have ceased when Higgins indicated he might need a lawyer. However, the judge ruled that this comment did not constitute a formal request for legal counsel.
Prosecutors’ Arguments
Prosecutors contended that Higgins acknowledged drinking earlier that day and had failed a field sobriety test prior to his arrest. They emphasized that the questioning during the investigation was standard procedure and not part of a custodial interrogation.
Judge Silvanio affirmed that all statements taken from Higgins were lawfully obtained and made voluntarily. He reiterated that the evidence depicted in the body-worn camera footage showed Higgins moving about freely, undermining the defense’s claims of coercion.
Potential Sentencing and Next Steps
Higgins, who was indicted in December 2024, declined a plea deal that would have resulted in a 35-year sentence. If convicted on all charges, he could face up to 70 years in prison. His next court appearance is set for December 15, 2024.
