Heisman Trophy Rankings: 4 Contenders and 3 Dark Horses for College Football’s Top Award

The race for the 2025 Heisman Trophy appears to have narrowed to four key quarterbacks, as reported by FanDuel. Indiana’s Fernando Mendoza currently leads the pack, closely followed by Julian Sayin from Ohio State, Marcel Reed of Texas A&M, and Alabama’s Ty Simpson. These four players have established themselves as frontrunners in the quest for college football’s prestigious individual award.

Top Contenders for the Heisman Trophy

1. Fernando Mendoza, QB, Indiana

Fernando Mendoza has emerged as the favorite after his thrilling game-winning touchdown pass against Penn State, solidifying his status. The Hoosiers are now 10-0 and the only unbeaten team in the country, making a strong case for Mendoza’s Heisman candidacy. With upcoming matches against Wisconsin and Purdue, his facing relatively weak defenses offers a chance to boost his stats before the Big Ten Championship Game on December 6. If Indiana finishes the season undefeated, it will mark their first perfect season since 1945, a narrative that Heisman voters often favor.

2. Marcel Reed, QB, Texas A&M

Marcel Reed is another strong candidate, playing a crucial role in Texas A&M’s undefeated record of 9-0. He has registered an impressive 19 touchdown passes, along with six rushing touchdowns, showcasing his versatility. The Aggies’ schedule includes a major rivalry game against Texas, providing Reed with an opportunity to make a notable impression on Heisman voters. Aiming for an undefeated finish would be significant for the program, as they last achieved this in 1939.

3. Julian Sayin, QB, Ohio State

Julian Sayin holds the second-best odds for the Heisman trophy, supported by Ohio State’s undefeated season and the team’s No. 1 national ranking. He ranks as one of the most efficient passers in college football. However, concerns about Ohio State’s relatively easy schedule could affect his chances. A strong performance against Michigan could enhance his narrative significantly.

4. Ty Simpson, QB, Alabama

Ty Simpson has bounced back since Alabama’s opening loss against Florida State and has since led the team through a challenging SEC schedule. He has completed 69% of his passes for over 1,000 yards this season against ranked teams, making a solid case for Heisman consideration. Despite not being the clear favorite, his performance could earn him a spot as a potential finalist in New York City.

Possible Dark Horses for the Heisman Trophy

While the top four contenders are generating buzz, several dark horses could still make significant impacts in the Heisman race.

• Diego Pavia, QB, Vanderbilt

  Pavia has transformed Vanderbilt’s team, leading them to an 8-2 record this season. If he can secure a win against Tennessee, he could elevate his Heisman profile dramatically.

• Haynes King, QB, Georgia Tech

  King has contributed significantly to Georgia Tech’s success, and his performance could shine in upcoming games, especially against Georgia.

• Jeremiah Smith, WR, Ohio State

  Smith is delivering impressive stats, ranking among the top receivers in the nation. A strong finish could help his Heisman chances as a wide receiver.

• Jeremiyah Love, RB, Notre Dame

  As one of the leading running backs, Love has an impressive record of 16 touchdowns. However, he faces historical challenges in the voting trend towards quarterbacks.

• Jacob Rodriguez, LB, Texas Tech

  Rodriguez has made a name for himself on defense, leading the nation in forced fumbles. Yet, being a linebacker adds to the challenges of winning the Heisman.

The Heisman race continues to evolve as the season progresses. These candidates will face significant challenges and opportunities in the coming weeks, with intriguing storylines developing around each player.