Packers Firmly Establish Position on Brandon McManus
The Green Bay Packers are facing growing frustration over their decision to maintain Brandon McManus as their kicker despite his ongoing struggles. His performance has been subpar since returning from a quad injury, making it the source of discontent for fans and analysts alike.
Brandon McManus’ Underwhelming Return
After a series of missed field goals, McManus has only converted four of his eight attempts since his return. His difficulty was evident in recent games, most notably missing a crucial 43-yarder against the Carolina Panthers. This miss contributed to a tight loss by three points. He also failed to connect on a 64-yard attempt against the Philadelphia Eagles in another close game.
Alternative Options
While McManus struggles, Lucas Havrisik has been performing well. During McManus’ absence due to injury, Havrisik filled in impressively, making all 10 of his attempts and setting a franchise record with a 61-yard field goal. His performance raised questions about why the Packers are not utilizing Havrisik as their primary kicker.
Coaching Decisions Under Scrutiny
Head coach Matt LaFleur and special teams coordinator Rich Bisaccia’s decisions have come under fire. Despite acknowledging McManus’ limited health—referred to as “semi-healthy”—they have continued to place him on the field. This raises concerns about their commitment to winning while sidelining a more efficient kicker.
The Impact on the Team
The team’s kicking situation has serious implications. By holding onto two kickers, the Packers had to waive tight end Ben Sims to make roster space, which further complicates their lineup. The decision-making process appears puzzling, especially with the team competing for wins.
Future Implications
As the pressures mount, fans and analysts are calling for a change. If McManus continues to miss kicks, the Packers may need to reconsider their strategy in the upcoming Week 11 game. The franchise’s current approach risks further jeopardizing their season and potential playoff aspirations.
- Brandon McManus: 4 of 8 field goals since returning
- Lucas Havrisik: Made all 10 field goal attempts while McManus was injured
- Franchise record: 61-yard field goal by Havrisik
- McManus missed key field goals against the Panthers and Eagles
- Roster implications: Waived tight end Ben Sims to accommodate two kickers
The Packers must address their kicking dilemma in order to enhance their chances of success as the season progresses. Without a clear resolution, the predicament may become more dire for the Green Bay franchise.
