Scarlett Johansson’s Eleanor the Great Disappoints Despite Stellar Performances

June Squibb recently celebrated her 96th birthday, marking a remarkable life in the entertainment industry. Born shortly after the 1929 stock market crash that initiated the Great Depression, Squibb began her theater career in 1951. She transitioned to television in 1985 and made her film debut in 1990 with Woody Allen’s *Alice*.

Notably, Squibb received an Oscar nomination for her role in *Nebraska* (2013) at age 85. At 94, she took on her first leading role in *Thelma*, and soon after, she appeared in *Eleanor the Great*, which also marks Scarlett Johansson’s directorial debut. This makes Squibb one of the oldest actresses in history to play a lead role in a feature film.

Challenges of *Eleanor the Great*

Despite the potential for compelling storytelling, *Eleanor the Great* faces numerous challenges. Films centered around elderly protagonists can struggle to engage audiences, often facing stereotypes of decline and isolation. While *Thelma* flourished as a heartfelt indie comedy, *Eleanor the Great* navigates more complex themes.

Storyline Overview

The script, penned by first-time screenwriter Tory Kamen, draws inspiration from an outspoken Jewish grandmother. Squibb’s character, Eleanor Morgenstein, lives independently in Florida with her friend Bessie Stern, played by Rita Zohar. The film delves into themes of loneliness among the elderly and the importance of intergenerational connections.

Plot Details

• Eleanor’s life takes a turn after Bessie passes away.
• She confronts strained relationships with her estranged daughter, Lisa, and grandson, Max.
• Eleanor inadvertently joins a Holocaust survivor support group, which leads to a pivotal deception.
• Her connection to the group reveals layers of her character and highlights her loneliness.

Despite Squibb’s commendable performance, critiques suggest that the film’s execution lacks finesse. Eleanor’s choice to impersonate a Holocaust survivor aims to honor Bessie but raises questions about authenticity and moral judgment.

Character Dynamics

Key characters include Nina Davis, a journalist and daughter of a prominent news anchor, who becomes entwined with Eleanor’s story. The film explores familial tensions while uncovering deeper emotional narratives.

Reception and Commentary

While *Eleanor the Great* strives to address meaningful themes, its predictability and tonal inconsistencies have been noted. Critics acknowledge the good intentions behind the film but express concerns about its storytelling execution. Ultimately, *Eleanor the Great* may find a more fitting audience on smaller screens.