Top 6 Yankees Center Field Options if Bellinger Leaves in Free Agency

Bassyonni

ago 2 hours

The New York Yankees face a critical offseason, particularly regarding their center field position. As both center fielders enter free agency, the team has become increasingly focused on potential replacements if Cody Bellinger leaves. The current situation emphasizes the urgency for New York to explore multiple options to avoid being left with a significant gap in their lineup.

Top 6 Yankees Center Field Options if Bellinger Leaves

Cody Bellinger, a standout player and former NL MVP, is a prime target for the Yankees this offseason. However, competition for his services is fierce, with teams like the Los Angeles Dodgers, New York Mets, Boston Red Sox, and Philadelphia Phillies also in pursuit. Bellinger’s projected value of approximately $180 million makes it critical for the Yankees to consider alternatives if a bidding war ensues.

1. Trade for Byron Buxton

Byron Buxton of the Minnesota Twins is a thrilling option, known for his electrifying play when healthy. Yet, health has been a significant concern, as Buxton has only played more than 100 games in a season three times since 2015. In 2025, he logged 126 games, hitting 35 home runs and stealing 24 bases. His contract is manageable, at just over $45 million for three years, but the Yankees would need to navigate Buxton’s no-trade clause.

2. Reunite with Trent Grisham

Trent Grisham’s future is uncertain after declining a qualifying offer. Previously considered for a bigger contract, he may now be less appealing due to draft compensation attached to his new contract. If the Yankees can secure him on a one-year deal, he could add depth to the center field position.

3. Promote Jasson Dominguez

Jasson Dominguez, a highly-touted prospect, had a mixed performance during his rookie season, posting a .719 OPS. Despite struggles, he is still a natural fit for center field. At just 22 years old, the Yankees might give him a chance to develop in a full-time role, considering his youthful potential.

4. Trade for Luis Robert Jr.

Recent discussions have linked the Yankees to Luis Robert Jr. of the Chicago White Sox. While he shares health concerns with Buxton, Robert’s abilities make him an intriguing possibility. In 2025, he managed to steal 33 bases and showed flashes of excellence offensively. His current contract could offer a cost-effective solution for the Yankees.

5. Promote Spencer Jones

Spencer Jones is another promising option, having excelled in the minors. Standing at six-foot-seven, he possesses impressive athleticism that has drawn comparisons to Aaron Judge. However, his strikeout rate raises concerns, making him a risky but potentially rewarding candidate for the outfield.

6. Sign Harrison Bader

Harrison Bader’s tenure with the Yankees has been lackluster, marred by injuries. With a career average of .627 OPS during his time in New York, Bader’s offensive contributions have been limited. Should Bader return, the Yankees would need to weigh the pros and cons of his defensive skills against his offensive decline.

Byron Buxton: $45 million over three years; health concerns.
Trent Grisham: Potential one-year deal after declining qualifying offer.
Jasson Dominguez: Young prospect; rookie season challenges.
Luis Robert Jr.: Versatile player with health history; potential for good value.
Spencer Jones: High-risk high-reward prospect with power but high strikeout rate.
Harrison Bader: Defensive skills may not offset offensive struggles.

As the Yankees navigate this offseason, evaluating these alternatives will be essential to maintaining a competitive edge in center field should Bellinger opt for another team. 귪