Ethan Hawke Shines in Blue Moon, Yet Film’s Uncertainty Prevails

Richard Linklater’s latest film, *Blue Moon*, features Ethan Hawke in a compelling role as Lorenz Hart, renowned lyricist. Set during the opening night of *Oklahoma!* in 1943, the film explores the complex dynamics of Hart’s life and career amidst personal struggles.

Ethan Hawke’s Performance Shines

Hawke delivers a powerful portrayal of Hart, who grapples with professional disappointment and alcoholism. Audiences witness a deeply emotional journey as Hart confronts the changing landscape of Broadway and his faltering partnership with composer Richard Rodgers, depicted by Andrew Scott.

Setting and Historical Context

The narrative unfolds primarily within Sardi’s, a famous New York City bar, where Hart reminisces about his past and critiques the new musical era ushered in by Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II. While the backdrop is rich with historical significance, the film takes creative liberties, prioritizing character exploration over strict accuracy.

• Time Period: 1943, during the opening of *Oklahoma!*
• Key Characters:
  • Ethan Hawke as Lorenz Hart
  • Andrew Scott as Richard Rodgers
  • Margaret Qualley as a Yale student

Thematic Exploration

The film delves into Hart’s struggles with identity and addiction, exemplified through his interactions with other characters, including a bartender played by Bobby Cannavale and writer E.B. White, portrayed by Patrick Kennedy. Hart’s romantic entanglement with a college student adds another layer to his complex persona.

Critique of Artistic Direction

Despite Hawke’s remarkable performance, *Blue Moon* has been criticized for its static presentation. The prolonged setting creates a sense of confinement, feeling more like a stage play than a fluid film experience. The focus also inadvertently highlights Hart’s physical stature, detracting from the narrative’s depth.

Historical Authenticity vs. Artistic License

The film includes historical references, such as the reunion between Rodgers and Hart to revive *A Connecticut Yankee*. However, some scenes raise questions about their authenticity. For instance, a moment with Stephen Sondheim introduces inaccuracies regarding his connection to Hart at such a young age.

• Challenges of Accuracy:
  • Moments that seem implausible can hinder the emotional impact.
  • Focus on Hart’s height distracts from the storytelling.

Conclusion

Ultimately, *Blue Moon* balances the line between historical fact and creative interpretation. While inaccuracies may frustrate purists, Hawke’s performance offers a poignant glimpse into the life of Lorenz Hart. The film invites viewers to reflect on broader themes of identity, loss, and the passage of time in the world of theater.