Michigan State Fires Jonathan Smith: Key Candidates, Transfers, and Recruits
The Michigan State football program has entered a pivotal transition following the dismissal of head coach Jonathan Smith, who was let go after a disappointing two-year stint, culminating in a 4-15 record. The move reflects the immense pressures of modern college football, where financial stakes and performance expectations are higher than ever.
Jonathan Smith’s Tenure and Its Challenges
Once a promising hire after a respectable run at Oregon State, Smith’s time at Michigan State began optimistically. He started his 2025 season with a 3-0 record, but the momentum quickly faded with four straight losses in the Big Ten.
His inability to connect with the program, combined with the departure of athletics director Alan Haller—who initially recruited him—compounded Smith’s challenges. Following Haller’s exit, new AD J Batt aimed to reshape the financial framework of Michigan State athletics, hinting that the program aims for greater competitiveness in the Big Ten.
Potential Coaching Candidates
With Smith’s departure, attention turns to potential successors. Here are five candidates being considered:
- Pat Fitzgerald: Formerly of Northwestern, Fitzgerald is known for leading a competitive program. He has experience with Big Ten championships, making him a strong fit for Michigan State.
- Pat Narduzzi: A former defensive coordinator at Michigan State, Narduzzi is a familiar face with a successful track record at Pitt and an affinity for the university.
- P.J. Fleck: The Minnesota coach has consistently reached bowl games and could bring stability and a cultural shift to Michigan State.
- Brian Kelly: Recently fired from LSU, Kelly has a significant coaching history in Michigan and could benefit from a return to a more comfortable setting.
- Brent Key: Currently at Georgia Tech, Key has impressed in the ACC and could provide a strong foundation based on his experience and success.
Key Players to Retain
The new coach will need to focus on retaining essential players amid this tumultuous period. Notable talents include:
- WR Nick Marsh: Emerging as one of the top young receivers, Marsh had 662 receiving yards and six touchdowns this season.
- QB Aidan Chiles: Following Smith from Oregon State, Chiles has potential as a young quarterback despite some struggles.
- LB Jordan Hall: A key leader on defense, Hall led the team in tackles and presents an opportunity for continuity.
- DT Derrick Simmons: As a highly regarded freshman, Simmons is an essential asset for the future.
- OT Conner Moore: A recent addition from Montana State, Moore’s experience enhances the offensive line for the upcoming season.
Significant Recruits
Michigan State also has pivotal recruits in the pipeline that the new coach will aim to retain:
- QB Kayd Coffman: The only current ESPN 300 recruit for the 2026 class, Coffman has significant potential as a quarterback.
- DE Fameitau Siale: A top defensive prospect, Siale is expected to draw interest from other programs due to his competitive stature.
- WR Samson Gash: The local prospect has generated attention and could be central to the team’s future success.
The transition following Jonathan Smith’s exit marks a critical moment for Michigan State football. With potential candidates in mind and important players to retain, the Spartans aim to re-establish their competitiveness in the Big Ten and beyond.
