Max Brosmer’s Poor Performance Among Worst-Rated QB Games Ever

Max Brosmer, an undrafted rookie free agent, faced significant challenges in his starting role during a recent game. The Vikings suffered a heavy defeat, losing 26-0 to the Seahawks. Brosmer’s performance was notably poor, earning him a 22.0 offensive grade and a 22.8 passing grade from Pro Football Focus (PFF).

Brosmer’s Historical Performance

According to PFF’s records, Brosmer’s scores nearly set the bar for the lowest single-game quarterback grades in history. Analyzing performances dating back to PFF’s inception in 2007, Brosmer’s game stands out as the worst among quarterbacks who attempted at least 20 passes in any game, regular season or postseason.

Comparison with Other Notable QB Performances

• Ryan Fitzpatrick’s notorious game in 2016 had a lower PFF grade, originally recorded at 21.4. Current assessments show Fitzpatrick with a 24.3 offensive score and a 25.7 passing score.
• Brosmer’s statistics include 19 completions on 30 attempts for 126 yards, with no touchdowns and four interceptions, which indicates a severe struggle.

While Brosmer’s performance was historically underwhelming, it is essential to consider context. Fitzpatrick’s game featured 20 completions on 44 attempts for 144 yards, accompanied by six interceptions.

Other Poor Performances

• Mac Jones, another quarterback cited for poor play in history, achieved a 20.9 offensive grade and a 22.6 passing grade in a 10-7 loss to the Giants in 2023. His stats included 12 completions out of 21 attempts for 89 yards and two interceptions.
• Nathan Peterman, infamous for his 2017 performance, recorded a 24.1 offensive grade and a 26.6 passing grade despite throwing five interceptions in the first half against Buffalo.
• Kendall Hinton also faced scrutiny for his performance in 2020, achieving a 24.3 passing grade despite a meager one completion for 13 yards and two interceptions.

Conclusion

No matter the comparisons, Brosmer’s outing is undeniably among the poorest performances from a quarterback in modern football. His struggle to find success on the field brings a focus to the challenges faced by undrafted rookies trying to make their mark in the NFL.