Are The Blueshirts Tough Enough for the Challenge?

In a recent game, the New York Rangers faced a notable challenge against the Tampa Bay Lightning. During this match, defenseman Adam Fox sustained a hit from Brandon Hagel. Despite the impact, no Rangers players retaliated, raising questions about the team’s toughness.

Rangers’ Reaction to the Hit

Veteran hockey analyst Al Greenberg expressed disappointment at the lack of response from the Rangers following the hit on Fox. Many observed that this absence of retaliation hinted at a perceived softness in the team’s demeanor. However, further examination of the incident suggests that Hagel’s hit was entirely legal under NHL rules.

• The hit featured Hagel with his stick down.
• He made contact with proper posture.
• Hagel finished through his opponent’s hands and arms.
• The execution of the hit was textbook, aligning with standard hockey practices.

While emotions often drive players to seek revenge after clean hits, the legality of Hagel’s play indicates that retaliation may not have been warranted.

Fan Perspectives on Toughness

Some Rangers fans feel differently. One loyal supporter claimed that, legal or not, Hagel’s action deserved payback. This sentiment reflects the tension between emotional reactions and the rules of the game.

Evaluating Rangers’ Toughness

The Rangers have faced scrutiny regarding their toughness, especially after a lackluster performance against a strong opponent like Tampa Bay. Despite claims of softness, notable players such as Sam Carrick and Will Cuylle, alongside Matt Rempe’s eventual return, suggest the roster has toughness embedded within it.

Jess Rubenstein, a respected scout, offers a nuanced perspective. He contends that rather than lacking toughness, the Rangers are “emotionally fragile.” This insight emphasizes that mental strength plays a critical role in a team’s performance, often impacting their responses to challenges.

Conclusion

As the New York Rangers continue their season, the question remains: Are the Blueshirts tough enough for the challenges ahead? Balancing legal hits with emotional responses will be crucial for their success in high-stakes games.