Giants Legend Carl Banks Criticizes Rookie Abdul Carter: ‘Grow Up’
Former New York Giants linebacker Carl Banks has voiced his concerns about rookie Abdul Carter’s performance and conduct. The third overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, Carter has recently faced criticism for tardiness that has led to multiple benchings.
Rookie’s Struggles on the Field
Abdul Carter, who was selected third overall in April 2025, has had a difficult start to his NFL career. The Penn State grad has only managed 1.5 sacks in his debut season. This disappointing production, coupled with disciplinary issues, has drawn the ire of Banks, who feels the rookie needs to step up.
Tardiness Controversy
Carter’s tardiness has directly affected his playing time. He missed the opening defensive series against the Green Bay Packers during Week 11. Just two weeks later, he was benched entirely for the first quarter during a Monday Night Football game against the New England Patriots.
Banks’ Tough Love
In his commentary on WFAN, Carl Banks did not hold back. He stated, “It’s time for the kid to grow up.” Banks emphasized that the rookie must take accountability as a high draft pick or risk further backlash.
Team Dysfunction
The Giants suffered a 33-15 loss to the Patriots, underscoring the issues plaguing the team. Banks pointed out instances of special teams errors and overall lack of discipline. He raised concerns about the broader implications of not addressing these issues promptly.
Leadership Under Scrutiny
Both interim head coach Mike Kafka and general manager Joe Schoen face scrutiny for allowing Carter’s issues to persist. Following the firing of head coach Brian Daboll, the pressure is mounting on Schoen, as fans call for accountability amidst a disappointing season.
A Pattern of Problems
- Carter’s tardiness has led to two benchings in three weeks.
- He managed only 1.5 sacks through 13 games.
- The Giants are facing criticism for overall team dysfunction.
Carl Banks’ critical perspective on Abdul Carter reflects a larger concern over several draft picks in recent years. As scrutiny grows, the Giants organization must address these issues to salvage their reputation and performance on the field.
