NY Giants’ GM Joe Schoen Evaluated on Performance, Not Press Statements
John Mara, co-owner of the New York Giants, confirmed in January that general manager Joe Schoen and head coach Brian Daboll will continue in their roles for a fourth season. This decision raised questions about the overall performance of the roster that Schoen has built since taking over in January 2022. When asked if the current roster was an improvement over the one Schoen inherited, Mara’s response indicated uncertainty, complicating the justification for maintaining the current leadership.
Mara emphasized the importance of collaboration and player responses when discussing Schoen’s potential, despite the team’s struggles. The Giants ended the 2024 season with a disappointing record of 2-11, mirroring their previous year’s results. Following the recent firing of Daboll and defensive coordinator Shane Bowen, Schoen remains in his position. He expressed confidence in his ability to rebuild the franchise despite the disappointing results.
Current Roster Evaluation
The New York Giants recently concluded the 2025 NFL Draft, selecting key players like Abdul Carter, a promising pass rusher, and Jaxson Dart, potentially their quarterback of the future. Free agency also brought in several players to bolster a defense that struggled in the previous season. Despite these efforts, the Giants find themselves in a precarious situation as they continue to struggle on the field.
Performance Statistics
- Overall Record: 20-43-1 under Schoen’s tenure.
- Winning Percentage: Decreased annually from .559 in 2022 to .154 this season.
Position Comparisons
A review of the roster from the end of the 2021 season compared to the 2025 season reveals both improvements and declines in various positions.
| Position | 2021 Roster | 2025 Roster | Evaluation |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quarterback | Daniel Jones, Mike Glennon | Jaxson Dart, Jameis Winston | Better |
| Running Back | Saquon Barkley, Devontae Booker | Tyrone Tracy, Devin Singletary | Even |
| Wide Receiver | Kenny Golladay, Sterling Shepard | Malik Nabers, Wan’Dale Robinson | Better |
| Tight End | Evan Engram | Theo Johnson, Daniel Bellinger | Better |
| Offensive Line | Andrew Thomas | Andrew Thomas, Jermaine Eluemunor | Better |
| Defensive Line | Dexter Lawrence, Leonard Williams | Dexter Lawrence, Rakeem Nunez-Roches | Worse |
| Linebacker | Tae Crowder | Bobby Okereke | Even |
| Cornerback | James Bradberry | Paulson Adebo | Worse |
| Safety | Xavier McKinney | Jevon Holland | Worse |
Future Outlook for Joe Schoen
The evaluation of Schoen’s performance will be crucial at the end of the season. The Giants’ ownership intends to assess the entire football operation, focusing on the effectiveness of the roster and coaching staff. Schoen remains hopeful about the potential of various young talents he has brought to the team, indicating a belief in their future contributions.
As the season progresses, the upcoming games against underperforming teams could be pivotal for Schoen’s job security. The Giants need at least two wins in their next three matches to reinforce the narrative that their talent surpasses their performance.
The conclusion of the 2025 season will be a decisive moment for Schoen, determining whether recent years of rebuilding can yield positive results for the franchise.
