Netflix Western Overlooks Female Stars

Netflix’s new series, “The Abandons,” offers an intriguing premise rooted in 1850s Westerns, crafted by acclaimed creator Kurt Sutter. Renowned for his work on “Sons of Anarchy,” Sutter brings a female-driven narrative to the forefront with Gillian Anderson and Lena Headey leading a compelling cast.

Plot Overview

“The Abandons” unfolds in Angel’s Ridge, Oregon, primarily focusing on two rival families in a gritty showdown reminiscent of the classic Hatfields vs. McCoys. Anderson plays Constance Van Ness, matriarch of a struggling aristocratic family whose mining operations are faltering. She is determined to expand her family’s influence to secure their future.

Opposing her is Fiona Nolan, portrayed by Headey, a resolute Irish homesteader. Fiona cares for four adopted orphans, creating a tense backdrop as both clans vie for control of the lucrative silver deposits in Jasper Hollow. The conflict escalates as personal and territorial stakes intertwine, leading to a cold war that soon turns chaotic.

Character Dynamics

• Gillian Anderson: As Constance Van Ness, she embodies a complex character torn between familial duty and moral dilemmas.
• Lena Headey: She portrays Fiona Nolan with fierce determination and compassion, balancing vulnerability with strength.
• Supporting Cast: Includes Lucas Till, Aisling Franciosi, Nick Robinson, Diana Silvers, Lamar Johnson, and Natalia del Riego, contributing to the overarching conflict.

Production and Direction

Produced with a backdrop of rich Western themes, “The Abandons” strives for depth but often relies on stock tropes. Despite its high ambitions, the series suffers from pacing issues, with episodes ranging from an hour to just over 30 minutes. This inconsistency affects viewer engagement and overall momentum.

Cultural Themes and Critique

The series attempts to address historical tensions, including the interactions between white settlers and Native American tribes, as well as the challenges faced by freed Black slaves. However, critics note these elements often feel like superficial additions to the main narrative, which primarily revolves around the melodrama of the feuding families.

Audience Reception and Future Prospects

The show’s reception remains uncertain, especially with Sutter’s departure shortly before the season’s conclusion. The finale sets up a cliffhanger, leaving viewers questioning the fates of key characters. Despite its engaging cast and standout production design, the series may struggle to secure a second season, as the novelty of its female-led storyline doesn’t fully compensate for the execution quality.

As “The Abandons” streams on Netflix, it stands as a reminder of the complexities and challenges in reimagining classic genres while aiming for a modern audience. The potential for growth exists, but depth and originality will be crucial for its future.