Top TV Shows of 2025: Critics’ Top Picks

As 2025 unfolds, television continues to captivate audiences with a remarkable array of innovative stories. From streaming platforms to traditional networks, the year offers a rich selection of diverse narratives that engage viewers with various genres, from true crime thrillers to period dramas. Critics Aramide Tinubu and Alison Herman of El-Balad have each compiled their top ten picks, showcasing standout shows that exemplify exceptional storytelling and character development.

Aramide Tinubu’s Top Picks for 2025

• 1. Adolescence (Netflix)

  This limited series delves into the complexities of incel culture through the tragic story of 13-year-old Jamie, who is accused of murder. The show highlights social media’s grim influence while employing a unique one-shot filming style.

• 2. The Pitt (HBO Max)

  A gripping medical drama set in Pittsburgh, this series follows Dr. Robby Robinavitch and his team during a challenging 15-hour shift. It emphasizes the harsh realities of America’s healthcare system.

• 3. Forever (Netflix)

  This teen romance, inspired by Judy Blume’s work, follows two high school athletes as they navigate love and life’s challenges in Los Angeles. It represents a heartfelt depiction of young Black love.

• 4. Paradise (Hulu)

  A political thriller that intertwines time and conspiracy, following Secret Service agent Xavier Collins after an assassination. Its unique narrative approach sets it apart from typical thrillers.

• 5. It: Welcome to Derry (HBO)

  The origin story of Pennywise takes viewers to 1962 Derry, Maine, exploring deeper societal issues amid horror. It intertwines themes of racism and psychological trauma with its chilling narrative.

• 6. Outlander: Blood of My Blood (Starz)

  This prequel explores love across different eras, showcasing the backstories of Claire and Jamie Fraser’s parents during post-World War I and early 18th-century Scotland.

• 7. A Thousand Blows (Hulu)

  Set in 1880 East London, this gritty tale follows Jamaican immigrants Hezekiah and Alec as they confront a hostile environment filled with crime and prejudice, intertwined with boxing.

• 8. Untamed (Netflix)

  This mystery-thriller captures the story of Agent Kyle Turner investigating a body found in Yosemite National Park while dealing with his own traumas that cloud his judgment.

• 9. The Gilded Age (HBO)

  The latest season of this period drama provides insight into 19th-century New York’s high society, focusing on character development and exploring themes of race and privilege.

• 10. Murdaugh: Death in the Family (Hulu)

  A compelling miniseries dramatizing the real-life Murdaugh family murders, showcasing themes of legacy, addiction, and familial dysfunction.

Alison Herman’s Top Picks for 2025

• 1. Andor (Disney+)

  This prequel to Rogue One expertly expands the Star Wars universe, focusing on the lives of ordinary individuals involved in political resistance, depicting rich character arcs.

• 2. Long Story Short (Netflix)

  This animated sitcom creatively explores grief through the lens of an urban Jewish family, mixing humor with deep emotional themes, reminiscent of previous works by its creator.

• 3. The Pitt (HBO Max)

  This Emmy-winning series is highlighted again for its authentic portrayal of trauma in a hospital setting, emphasizing character development over sensational storylines.

• 4. Dying for Sex (FX)

  A series about a terminally ill woman’s journey of self-discovery and connection, unearthing sincere themes of friendship and agency in the face of mortality.

• 5. The Righteous Gemstones (HBO)

  The popular comedy illustrates the excesses of a televangelist family while addressing deeper societal hypocrisies, maintaining a balance of humor and critique.

• 6. The Lowdown (FX)

  This detective mystery set in Tulsa examines historical injustices while weaving a complex narrative that’s both engaging and thought-provoking.

• 7. Everybody’s Live with John Mulaney (Netflix)

  Mulaney’s innovative talk show combines humor and celebrity culture in a unique format that has resonated with audiences despite uncertainty about its future.

• 8. The Gilded Age (HBO)

  Returning for a third season, the show’s exploration of society and character dynamics continues to overcome its prior shortcomings, providing a richer storyline for its characters.

• 9. Pluribus (Apple TV)

  This thought-provoking project from Vince Gilligan tackles the implications of a hive mind with a remarkable blend of drama and inquiry into the human condition.

• 10. The Studio (Apple TV)

  A heartfelt Hollywood satire that showcases the trials of filmmaking and the spirit behind creative endeavors, presenting a refreshing take on industry challenges.

These selections reflect the diverse storytelling landscape of 2025, offering viewers numerous options for entertainment and thought-provoking narratives.