Boston Pastor Defies Order to Remove Anti-ICE Nativity Scene
The ongoing dispute regarding the anti-ICE Nativity display at St. Susanna Church in Dedham, Massachusetts, has garnered significant attention. Father Stephen Josoma, the parish pastor, has chosen to keep the display active despite calls for its removal from the Archdiocese of Boston.
Background of the Display
On November 29, 2025, the controversial Nativity scene was installed outside the church. It features a prominent sign reading “ICE Was Here” and indicates that the Holy Family figures are safely housed within the church. Additionally, the display includes a phone number for reporting U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents.
Archdiocesan Response
After the display’s installation, Archbishop Richard Henning of Boston instructed Father Josoma to remove it. The archbishop described the display as inappropriate, adding that churchgoers expect an environment conducive to prayer rather than political messaging.
- Archdiocesan spokesman Terrence Donilon emphasized that using sacred images for political purposes contradicts church norms.
- He confirmed that St. Susanna Parish did not seek permission to display the anti-ICE messaging.
Father Josoma’s Position
Father Josoma remains steadfast in his belief that the display is not sacrilegious. He argues that any perceived divisiveness stems from larger societal issues rather than the message conveyed through the Nativity scene. The pastor expressed surprise at the archbishop’s firm stance.
- During a press conference on December 7, he stated, “Our display aligns with the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ message on immigration.”
- He conveyed that the parish council would convene to discuss how to respond to the archbishop’s request.
Legal Perspective
According to canon law expert David Long, while pastors usually have authority over their parishes, bishops can impose directives under specific circumstances. The archbishop’s actions fall within his responsibilities to maintain unity and avoid scandal within the diocese.
- Long explains that the display could be seen as a potential canonical offense if the pastor continues to defy the directive.
- He noted that a parish council does not have the authority to overrule the bishop’s directives.
Community Reactions
This incident has sparked a variety of reactions among community members and the wider church community. As debates continue regarding the intersection of faith and political issues, St. Susanna’s anti-ICE Nativity display remains at the forefront of discussions about immigration enforcement and social justice.
As the situation develops, both Father Josoma and Archbishop Henning are expected to engage in further dialogue regarding the display’s future.
