Architects Urge Shalom Baranes Associates to Reject Trump Commission
A group of 29 architects from the American Institute of Architects (AIA) has formally urged Shalom Baranes Associates to decline its involvement with a controversial project under the Trump administration. The project involves the redevelopment of the White House East Wing ballroom, which has attracted significant criticism.
Architects Call for Action Against Trump Commission
In a letter dated December 10, 2023, the architects argued that proceeding with the “sole source commission” could violate the AIA’s Code of Ethics & Professional Conduct. The signatories profess that their concerns stem from the possible ethical implications surrounding the project’s execution.
Background on the Letter
This correspondence follows another letter sent on November 21, which addressed James McCrery’s involvement in the East Wing redesign. McCrery resigned from the project in October due to similar ethical concerns surrounding the demolition of the historic building to make way for a larger event space.
Reasons for Rejection
The architects outlined three critical reasons for their request:
- The demolition occurred without public input.
- The proposed ballroom’s dimensions exceed that of both the White House and West Wing combined, potentially diminishing the complex’s stature.
- The awarding of the commission to Shalom Baranes Associates may not have followed proper protocol.
The letter implores Baranes to “do what you know is right” and reassess acceptance of the commission. The architects indicated their intention to allow Baranes an opportunity to explain his decisions before pursuing formal ethical complaints.
Potential Ethical Violations
As an AIA member, Shalom Baranes is subject to the organization’s ethical guidelines. The letter cautions that his involvement may breach several rules outlined in the AIA’s Code of Ethics & Professional Conduct. Violations could lead to disciplinary actions such as admonition, suspension, or even termination of membership.
Progress of the Ballroom Project
Despite the controversies and the change in architects, the project’s parameters remain unchanged. Reports this week have noted that construction is ongoing, with foundations being laid where the East Wing previously stood. Will Scharf from the National Capital Planning Commission anticipates receipt of design plans from the Trump administration for the new ballroom this month.
As the debate continues, the situation highlights significant ethical concerns within modern architectural practices, particularly regarding historic preservation and community involvement.
