Yankees Update: Volpe Faces Competition; Wells Addresses Catching Role

The New York Yankees are entering a season marked by uncertainty regarding shortstop Anthony Volpe and catcher Austin Wells. Both players are key figures for the club, yet face distinct challenges as they prepare for the upcoming MLB season.

Volpe’s Competition for Shortstop Position

General manager Brian Cashman has hinted at potential competition for Volpe upon his return from shoulder surgery. The procedure is expected to sideline him for over a month at the beginning of the season. Cashman indicated that roster performance would dictate playing time, stating, “People continue to earn their playing time or they don’t.”

At this point, José Caballero is expected to step in as the starting shortstop. Caballero, who is 29 years old, has shown strong defensive skills and base-stealing ability, though he carries a career OPS of .686. The Yankees have not ruled out acquiring a different shortstop as the offseason progresses.

Commentary from Management

• Cashman expressed confidence in Volpe’s potential despite his challenges last season, affirming, “Do I believe in Anthony Volpe? The answer is yes.”
• Manager Aaron Boone reiterated this support, highlighting the importance of Volpe’s development in both offense and defense.

The Yankees drafted Volpe in the first round in 2019. He advanced quickly through the minors, demonstrating both high offensive abilities and questionable defense. However, Volpe surprised many by winning a Gold Glove as a rookie in 2023, despite having a career OPS of only .662.

Austin Wells and the Catching Situation

Catcher Austin Wells made his MLB debut last season, playing 19 games. His performance metrics indicate a drop in overall production, as he recorded a 0.1 WAR in 2023 compared to the same figure in 2024, despite playing 126 games. His offensive statistics show a stark decline, achieving a .219 batting average with 21 home runs and 71 RBIs in 448 plate appearances.

Future Outlook for Wells

Despite the downturn, the Yankees are inclined to keep Wells as their starting catcher heading into 2026. Cashman believes in Wells’ talent and potential, suggesting there is more offensive ability to be tapped into moving forward.

• Wells finished third in the American League Rookie of the Year voting in 2024.
• Current projections show Ben Rice and JC Escarra as potential backups for Wells.

Cashman acknowledged the challenges of the catching market, stating it is a “very thin market” with limited options. The Yankees may prioritize finding support for Wells but are prepared to head into the next season without a right-handed backup for him.

In summary, the New York Yankees are poised for an intriguing season ahead. The competition for Volpe’s position may redefine the team’s strategy, while Wells’s return to form will be closely monitored. Management’s confidence in both players will be critical as the team navigates these challenges.